Should Some Folders Be Eliminated Or Combined?

[7thElement]

Fell free to post comments in addition to your vote

[FuNkY CaPrIcOrN]

:huh: Folders?What Folders? :huh:

[Spider_dude]

i think he means forums.

[4play]

definetly musicworld first :P

[7thElement]

Yes by folders I mean each particular section on the forum.

7th

[jetje]

If so i can imagine klite section becomes a part of the filesharing section and the talk section and lounge can be one ;)

For the rest i like it the way it is now.

[vivitron 15]

make some into subfolders - i.e. all the filesharing ones part of Fileshareworld, and stick with the other worlds

[CornerPocket]

I'd say eliminate DC++ & Shareaza and place the post in 'Other Related'.

[bujub22]

yah stop the changes and leave stuff the way it is ,..if it's not broke ....well u know the rest :D

[RGX]

Originally posted by vivitron 15@25 March 2004 - 18:16
make some into subfolders - i.e. all the filesharing ones part of Fileshareworld, and stick with the other worlds
IMO opinion bujub, some of it is "broke" :D.

I agree with the person i quoted :).

[DanB]

Originally posted by jetje@25 March 2004 - 19:00
If so i can imagine klite section becomes a part of the filesharing section and the talk section and lounge can be one ;)

For the rest i like it the way it is now.
I thought the whole idea of the talk club and the lounge was that worthy threads was seperated from the shit? :rolleyes:

Surely combining the two will leave egg on someone's face?

[tracydani]

I voted no, but would go with jetje, Vivitron 15 and CP's suggestions though. Just keep the various apps as separate subfolders if you can.

TD

[TRshady]

Thanks for the poll 7th .. I appreciate it. :)
As for me .. I went for "combine folders" ...... seems most think the same.

[h1]

Consolidate some worlds, ie move SoulSeek to MusicWorld. :)

[Skillian]

I voted to combine a few. All the Kazaa Lite related could go into one, apart from the development bit, Shareaza and DC++ could go into Other Related P2P, and I'm still not convinced about the codec forum and Bookworld.

I liked the idea about two seperate lounges and wish it had worked, but it clearly doesn't look like it has.

I like the layout of the board but we have spread ourselves a little too thinly.

[FuNkY CaPrIcOrN]

Originally posted by haxor41789@25 March 2004 - 19:42
Consolidate some worlds, ie move SoulSeek to MusicWorld. :)
:D It will be so popular again. :D

:P And if sharedholder wants to say blubster should be in MusicWorld lets do a Poll.Am sure SS will win big time for Music. :P

Lets do it.....

:01: Blubster vs. SoulSeek War! :01:

[Adster]

Originally posted by FuNkY CaPrIcOrN@26 March 2004 - 10:45

:01: Blubster vs. SoulSeek War! :01:
:Bring: it on :devil:devil:

[kAb]

This is like a FOXNews poll :lol:

Yes eliminate some of them
No I like the organization

What if we liked them but didn't think it was organized?

[Cyril]

@ kAb - That's what comments are for.

@ 7th - good on you for putting the poll up.

[supersonic]

Merging some boards (folders) will improve the forum. For example, Bittorent, Emule, Edonkey, Shareaza should all go under one category, since Shareaza has them all. Soulsee# and blubster should go into music world. Luonges should be combined and posts should not be count. Internet world should be put in a subfolder under "Software world", since 99.98987% of the internet is software. That also applies to Games world, but Internet/Games world are somewhat active, so you could leave them alone. Codec pack discussion/dev. should be combined into 1.
The above is just IMO, I could be wrong and I do not respresent everyone, but only myself.

[RealitY]

Thanks for the poll, I guess I finally whined my way into your heart or brain. I voted for delete although combine actually make more sense, though either or.

My main bone has always been in the Filesharing sections and I think moving some of the worlds like mIRC back to a simple nice and tidy pinned topic within "Other Filesharing Apps" would be much more effective, as for my ideas they have been repeated by me once too many so I am sure you know how I feel and what I think is best for this forum...

[Nightwolf]

I think you can safely eliminate all the Requests subforums, as most people usually make their requests in the top tier Worlds.

I also think Movieworld should have a subforum for TV Shows. I know it's been hotly debated before, but I still think they're two very different things and they each deserve a different chat area.

[Rappy]

I think makeing all of the fileshareing forums a subforums is a good idea.

Also funnystuff should be a subforum of the lounge.

[7thElement]

Ok so we have the following folders. What do you guys suggest? Should we simply make them all subfolders under "General Filesharing Talk" or should we move all content into Other related P2P Programs, or should we do something else? I need some guidance here :-)

General Filesharing Talk

Bittorrent

E-Donkey & E-Mule

DC++

(M)IRC

Shareaza

Soulseek

Other Related P2P Program Discussions

[Rappy]

I think under fileshareing talk. All of those forums aren't that popular like musicworld or the lounge is so putting them all into a subforum i think is for the best.

I also think that the fileshareing section should be moved ubove the codics section.


Personally i think codics dhould be a subforum too but where should it go software world?

[sharedholder]

Originally posted by FuNkY CaPrIcOrN+26 March 2004 - 00:45--></div><table border='0' align='center' width='95%' cellpadding='3' cellspacing='1'><tr><td>QUOTE (FuNkY CaPrIcOrN @ 26 March 2004 - 00:45)</td></tr><tr><td id='QUOTE'> <!--QuoteBegin-haxor41789@25 March 2004 - 19:42
Consolidate some worlds, ie move SoulSeek to MusicWorld. :)
:D It will be so popular again. :D

:P And if sharedholder wants to say blubster should be in MusicWorld lets do a Poll.Am sure SS will win big time for Music. :P

Lets do it.....

:01: Blubster vs. SoulSeek War&#33; :01: [/b][/quote]
:lol: :01: :01: :01: POLL, POLL, POLL :01: :01: :01: :rolleyes:

[Rappy]

Originally posted by sharedholder+26 March 2004 - 14:19--></div><table border='0' align='center' width='95%' cellpadding='3' cellspacing='1'><tr><td>QUOTE (sharedholder @ 26 March 2004 - 14:19)</td></tr><tr><td id='QUOTE'>
Originally posted by FuNkY CaPrIcOrN@26 March 2004 - 00:45
<!--QuoteBegin-haxor41789@25 March 2004 - 19:42
Consolidate some worlds, ie move SoulSeek to MusicWorld. :)
:D It will be so popular again. :D

:P And if sharedholder wants to say blubster should be in MusicWorld lets do a Poll.Am sure SS will win big time for Music. :P

Lets do it.....

:01: Blubster vs. SoulSeek War&#33; :01:
:lol: :01: :01: :01: POLL, POLL, POLL :01: :01: :01: :rolleyes: [/b][/quote]
Stop spamming

[sharedholder]

Originally posted by RapFan@26 March 2004 - 14:20
Stop spamming
Have you tried Blubster ? :angry: :angry: :angry:

[jetje]

for a poll check musicworld :rolleyes:

[sharedholder]

Originally posted by 7thElement@26 March 2004 - 14:12
Ok so we have the following folders.&nbsp; What do you guys suggest?&nbsp; Should we simply make them all subfolders under "General Filesharing Talk" or should we move all content into Other related P2P Programs, or should we do something else?&nbsp; I need some guidance here :-)&nbsp;

General Filesharing Talk

&nbsp; Bittorrent

&nbsp; E-Donkey & E-Mule

DC++

&nbsp; (M)IRC

&nbsp; Shareaza

&nbsp; Soulseek

Other Related P2P Program Discussions
I already told you long time ago that the new section( worlds) killed the board, now you have the prove.You didn&#39;t listen to me that time and maybe you don&#39;t listen this time too, anyway i try again. :)

Bittorent

e2dk Network = E-Donkey & E-Mule & Shareazaa


Other Related P2P Program Discussions = Sections = DC + (M)IRC + Misc crap programs .

Fasttrack = Kazaa Lite, Mamouth, etc...

Musicworld = Soulseek + Blubster

[Rappy]

I don&#39;t like that plan <_<

[TRshady]

Nor me, lol.... and I think it would be great to have soulseek and blubster as subforums. I also think we should lose the whole " Kazaa Lite Related " category as simply have that as a &#39;folder&#39; ....

[FuNkY CaPrIcOrN]

;) Hardly anybody uses Blubster.The Poll is showing that.

[RealitY]

Originally posted by 7thElement@26 March 2004 - 06:12
move all content into Other related P2P Programs
Thats how it used to be an it wasn&#39;t broke then.

The topics as I&#39;ve mention such as Noob IRC Help (http://filesharingtalk.com/index.php?showtopic=69650), Private Bt Tracker (http://filesharingtalk.com/index.php?showtopic=41113), Soulseek Klf Music World (http://filesharingtalk.com/index.php?showtopic=45353) and others that would be considered of importance should be pinned topics within, perhaps SoulSeek should move back to MusicWorld as it was before as it seemed to draw more attention when it was there.

As for other apps like DC++ and Blubster and those that may be offened by the merge and getting lost within, well I can simply say if you can draw the same attention that SoulSeek and FastTracker has then you should be pinned as well.

As we did once before as new communities started to develop they were pinned and stayed pinned unless they lost interest. This is why having Blubster pinned makes no sence because its not a community, just like Ares or Overnet perhaps, they may be great apps but they are not community based.

I am however a little clueless what should be done with Bittorent since it is rather large and use to overflow Other related P2P Programs. I guess a thought would be to have a EDK2/BT Forum, that could cover eMule, eDonkey, Shareaza and Bittorent all in one. Although if I had to choose I would say just one heading for all under Other related P2P Programs and keep it simple and clean...

[TRshady]

Originally posted by FuNkY CaPrIcOrN@26 March 2004 - 18:06
;) Hardly anybody uses Blubster.The Poll is showing that.
Its relavtively new .... not many people know how to make it clean, and soulseek has always been a firm favourite and &#39;home&#39; of many users here ... give it time.

[RealitY]

Originally posted by TRshady+26 March 2004 - 10:36--></div><table border='0' align='center' width='95%' cellpadding='3' cellspacing='1'><tr><td>QUOTE (TRshady &#064; 26 March 2004 - 10:36)</td></tr><tr><td id='QUOTE'> <!--QuoteBegin-FuNkY CaPrIcOrN@26 March 2004 - 18:06
;) Hardly anybody uses Blubster.The Poll is showing that.
Its relavtively new .... not many people know how to make it clean, and soulseek has always been a firm favourite and &#39;home&#39; of many users here ... give it time. [/b][/quote]
Well the truth is Ares has just surpassed the 300,000 mark and still growing while the MP2P network is standing still at around 250,000 for some time. Also as I&#39;ve said above I don&#39;t see how an app like Blubster can be considered community based like SoulSeek, this is the reason SoulSeek has become so popular, not to also mention the ability to grab an entire album with one click that is a complete rip from one place with one app that ripped it, not a bunch of singles that have been pieced together...

[TRshady]

Blubster for me is a saviour simply because I used kazaa for all my music and now thats messed up, blubster really seems to shine when it comes to single mp3&#39;s. I get ALL the albums I need form emule and BT at great speeds .. here is the community Im glad to be proud of and some of you will know I have tried soulseek .. few times, but simply prefere how I currently do things. Not saying soulseek is crap .. I know it isn&#39;t .. each to his own it seems.

[Rappy]

Will there be a change?

[supernico]

I give a vote for a new BLUBSTER section&#33;

To anybody that has doubts. Just try it once&#33; It has the best speeds guaranteed for music.

[CPU1]

even if this is true. thats not a reason for having its own section. just look at all the others. they are like ghost towns. the only one that seems to be active is the bt one

[RealitY]

So far 42 Yes, 8 No...

[jetje]

Originally posted by REALITY@28 March 2004 - 13:04
So far 42 Yes, 8 No...
Well 14 don&#39;t want or don&#39;t care, that&#39;s a lot of support for leaving things the way they are :lol: So don&#39;t be to sure of them coming :lol:

[RealitY]

Well currently I see...

Yes - 45
No - 7
DC - 8

I dont think "Don&#39;t Care" sould be considered as "Leave It Alone" or either as support to do so, if so they would most likely have voted "No" since that clearly requests to "Leave It Alone". These are perhaps people that don&#39;t even visit forums that may be affected by these suggested changes.

Actually if I wanted to play the other card I could say they "Don&#39;t Care" to have the changes done, so then those votes would become considered "Yes" votes as well.
:huh: :huh:

"Don&#39;t Care" is simply that, a null vote, nothing more, nothing less, I don&#39;t think we should attempt to interput what they want since they "Don&#39;t Care" for a varity of reasons.
:lol: :lol:

As I see it, its 45 - 7 right now, almost near 90%, I think that speak rather loudly.
:D :D

[Rappy]

However you consider it most people here want a change.

[fkdup74]

Originally posted by FuNkY CaPrIcOrN@25 March 2004 - 16:45
:P And if sharedholder wants to say blubster should be in MusicWorld lets do a Poll.Am sure SS will win big time for Music. :P

:devil: i say let em, we can spy on em that much easier :devil:

(and in their defense, it is an mp3 only network) :P

[fkdup74]

-edit- LMAO, misread the post, my bad :P

[Mad Cat]

No point in having 4 kazaa lite boards, thats no longer the boards base and its all but dead anyway.

Codecs needed too? Subforum in a Dev forum would do methinks.

[thewizeard]

Originally posted by 4play@25 March 2004 - 17:40
definetly musicworld first :P
:o Profetic... :o

[fkdup74]

Originally posted by supernico@28 March 2004 - 02:18
I give a vote for a new BLUBSTER section&#33;

To anybody that has doubts. Just try it once&#33; It has the best speeds guaranteed for music.
you dont browse the forum much do you? <_<
it has a section.....<----meant forum, but forgot it was abandoned
it was a different site, but linked in lots of sigs here,
so it was just like another section of the board :lol:

and speeds are a non-issue, i know, i have tried em both ;)
it all boils down to who you connect to

[bootylicious]

Combining some folders would (I hope) reduce the chance of people posting in the wrong section....DUH NOT&#33; :lol: :lol: