Comparison of what, waffles and stmusic

[Submission]

For all of you that are wondering. Here's a comparison between the 3.

STMusic:
Registered users 42,679
Torrents 24,108

what:
Registered users 8,505
Torrents 14,046

waffles:
Registered users 1,793
Torrents 9,131


Looking at waffles and what cd, they have entirely scene releases. The avg music tracker that has scene uploaders has 14,000 scene releases.

At this point its what.cd vs stmusic but what.cd as a real long way to go.

[yazh58]

For all of you that are wondering. Here's a comparison between the 3.

STMusic:
Registered users 40,003
Torrents 22,505

what:
Registered users 8,505
Torrents 14,046

waffles:
Registered users 1,793
Torrents 9,131

Looking at waffles and what cd, they have entirely scene releases. The avg music tracker that has scene uploaders has 14,000 scene releases.

At this point its what.cd vs stmusic but what.cd as a real long way to go.

i have what.cd and stmusic. both pretty good, but i'm still wonderin about waffle.

[_asd_]

Stmusic has awful design and doesn't have any community. Almost the same goes with what.cd. /me looking forward to joining waffles. I have a good feeling about it.

[Grind$oFine]

What and Waffles kind of make me mad just because they weren't thinking when they opened.
Why didn't they prepare for all the people better?
Waffles had all this talk about invites being easy to get when they opened, and all this talk about it being easy... and now they're open and no invites because they need a new server....
and what.cd is full and slow as all hell... and numerous other issues...

they made/opened their sites as OiNK replacements... yet... look at how they're doing.

STMusic has been around longer and I think they are the most reliable in the situation.. and reliability gets my vote.

[beat]

For all of you that are wondering. Here's a comparison between the 3.

STMusic:
Registered users 40,003
Torrents 22,505

what:
Registered users 8,505
Torrents 14,046

waffles:
Registered users 1,793
Torrents 9,131

Looking at waffles and what cd, they have entirely scene releases. The avg music tracker that has scene uploaders has 14,000 scene releases.

At this point its what.cd vs stmusic but what.cd as a real long way to go.

What about adding the opening date of the sites? This way it looks biased.

[AkaiDoresu]

actually 9000 torrents in 3-4 days i v. nice, waffles.fm is doing great job, i think it will be between what.cd and waffles

[Alien5]

this article explains the madness of the day waffles closed signups:

http://blog.wired.com/27bstroke6/200...annabe---.html

[HMthePM]

STMusic is nice but I dont like its site design, looks like I am moving through shitbag.

[Submission]

actually 9000 torrents in 3-4 days i v. nice, waffles.fm is doing great job, i think it will be between what.cd and waffles

automated servers uploading the latest scene releases.

Means absolutely nothing. Oink was great because of user uploads, this attitude persevered in stmusic.

We've all seen what happens to over hyped sites, scn, rts etc. They have the nice initial burst of torrents and users with multiple accounts to trade.

Then they have no leechers because there is actually no one using the site let alone upload.

Why do you think they gave everyone 10g upload? Do you know of any site that gives 10g to EVERYONE? They're desperate. No one uses what.cd because there is simply no reason to with stmusic growing fast and well.

[Fibo]

Although im not a member of either waffles or What, im still gonna have to go with ST dont get me wrong, I wouldnt mind being a member of all threee, but im happy where I am now.

As stated above:

STMusic has been around longer and I think they are the most reliable in the situation.. and reliability gets my vote.