Sites ranked level 10

[ecin]

Based on that scc should have 10/10 too. For their categories it's ok then I guess, as they're best available there.
If you compare all categories, TT would probably be the only real 10/10, seeing it has only trance/techno compared to the amount of its quality torrents. Else OiNK would have had 20/10 or something :f

So far my opinion

Btw, why is BCG not [10] ?

I think the quality rating is subjective, based on the taste of the reviewer. The quality rating tends to be quite fixed as opposed to the rarity ranking where there are parties with interest that are trying to push the trackers up/down the list and make it more dynamic.

I've just read this post. I think he is very right.

Also it's very unclear what the ratings are actually based on. They appear sorta fuzzy, which automatically leeds to a partially biased result.
They should be more detailed.
But in the end, every person will have his/her own rating, based on personal taste, anyway.

[bikernin]

i agree with pro267 that the ratings are highly subjective. we can only say which tracker is best in its respective category although there will still be considerable debate on that for the 0day trackers. BMTV, BCG, HDBits are the absolute bests in their categories.
Also, a perfect 10 implies that the site has the best content with little or no scope for improvement. in this respect i feel that there are very few sites which derserve a perfect 10 because most of these sites have a lot of scope for improvement

[KFlint]

blackcats and revtt are now rated 10 also btw

[krunktastic]

blackcats and revtt are now rated 10 also btw

A 10 should justify an essentially perfect site (i.e. barely any more content could improve the tracker, speeds are always maxed, highly active communities, variety, etc) and there's no way we should be pushing for MORE 10's. There should be very few (IF ANY) all around 10's. Yes, BlackCats is an awesome gaming site. Is it absolutely perfect in every way? Is TL absolutely equal to ScT? These ratings need to be SERIOUSLY reconsidered before they become laughed at as much as the "rarity ratings" which cause so much more trouble than they're worth. Rating trackers should be done by averaging a cumulative vote on the criteria, not just giving some arbitrary number to try and please the public. If FST expects anyone to take them seriously, they need to get rid of the 10's and start rating these trackers as 7's, 8's, and 9's. VERY FEW trackers are *PERFECT*.



Nice1 guy below me.

[disconny]

puretna should get a 10

[Adman65]

i almost like TR better than TT....

[KFlint]

blackcats and revtt are now rated 10 also btw

A 10 should justify an essentially perfect site (i.e. barely any more content could improve the tracker, speeds are always maxed, highly active communities, variety, etc) and there's no way we should be pushing for MORE 10's. There should be very few (IF ANY) all around 10's. Yes, BlackCats is an awesome gaming site. Is it absolutely perfect in every way? Is TL absolutely equal to ScT? These ratings need to be SERIOUSLY reconsidered before they become laughed at as much as the "rarity ratings" which cause so much more trouble than they're worth. Rating trackers should be done by averaging a cumulative vote on the criteria, not just giving some arbitrary number to try and please the public. If FST expects anyone to take them seriously, they need to get rid of the 10's and start rating these trackers as 7's, 8's, and 9's. VERY FEW trackers are *PERFECT*.



Nice1 guy below me.

you are taking this a little bit too seriously imo, no need to create a comitee to vote for tracker ratings

it's just logical that the best game tracker (by far) get a 10 for outstanding quality

if we wait for absolute perfection, none would ever be rated 10 because perfection is not human

[ceasar]

Do you think there are other sites who deserve to get a perfect 10 ?

Absolutely:
Bitme should be rated 10, the other ones: TheVault - perfect 10 in it's category.
Sport trackers: 5minsforfighting getting 10 - content is very good there's no other hockey tracker at all, also would give lots of respect to Sportbit and Sport-scene, but here's the catch none of them probably can't get 10, because some torrents are on one tracker, some on the other, but Sportbit + Sport-Scene = 10 in it's category - Basketball.

[t0mmy]

if its just judged on content, then what about mma-tracker, it has everything, and one of my favourite trackers now

[Dark Archon]

i have TL and TTi i think that

TL - it's very fast pre-time and very good 0day releases. I think it's a lot better than Revtt (it doesn't show pre-time)

TTi - there is the poker cup thing..also the web interface is very techish, and it has Free Leech Movie of the Day so that is really nice.