You have a bite there JPaul...dont reel him in too quick now..
Broken
You have a bite there JPaul...dont reel him in too quick now..
An It Harm None, Do What You Will
I share more files than you can imagine. This persona shares in excess of 14,000 - over 110 GB.Originally posted by ripley02@31 July 2003 - 22:01
so do you yourself participate in filesharing? and not as means to share bogus files. let me ask you this also, since you are employee of riaa/mpaa do they make you sign or agree not to use any p2p programs? if you do use p2p for illegal means then why do you work for antipiracy organization but only if you do.
It's not illegal, I work for the people who own the copyright, therefore I have permission to do what I want with them. That's the point.
Of course I don't sign that I won't use p2p, that's what I'm paid to do. Share files to get the IP of people who get them from me.
It is legal for me to put them online, it is illegal for you to take them. It's like the police leaving a car unlocked (called a rat trap). If you take it it is theft.
Please feel free to come over to the Soul Seek room and ask after me. I use a different name there, but I am the one with around 14,500 files, normally the second or third highest. Most people there can identify my name there. In fact minimal research here will identify that other name.
Download what you want, please.
I don't think they would waste time on a discussion board
Member
Jpaul - thats so crazy! so if you get more of the same Ip that people download from you they are most likely to be put on the list?
Can the RIAA actually do that? Give one person permission to give away a song, but not give permission to the other guy to recieve it?How could it be given away if it can't get recieved?
That's like handing a guy a baseball bat, asking him to hit me, then suing him when he does it.
BT Rep: +10
People who are parnoid are just letting the RIAA win
I love the challenge becaseu i knwo Ill win easy
not only are the RIAA on the board they are jacking off to sweet sweet kazaa porn at blazing speeds...damn pigs
Of course we can. If you own the copyright you can do what you want with the file. That's the point.Originally posted by DasScoot@1 August 2003 - 05:47
Can the RIAA actually do that? Give one person permission to give away a song, but not give permission to the other guy to recieve it?
That's like handing a guy a baseball bat, asking him to hit me, then suing him when he does it.
I make it available, but I don't give you my permission to take it.
Think about the car again. If I leave e my car open, with the key in the ignition and the engine running can you drive away in it.
No it would be stealing.
If I leave my front door open, can you come in and take what you want.
No it would be stealing.
If I have files on my hard drive and you can see them can you take them.
No it's still stealing.
Think about it, the logical way to catch you is for me to place the files there. Then when you take them i can get your IP. With your IP I can go to your ISP and get your details. The rest is a piece of cake. People will be prosecuted when we are ready to do it, not when it suits you. The evidence is being gathered.
It doesn´t involve baseball bats at all.
nice little story, with the car and shit,
Have you heard of
Entrapment
Yes if i stole the car, and you had leave the door open, with the engine running, waiting for me to steal it, then in court the case would be thrown out because its entrapment.
Because you have not alarmed your car or taken security procusions which is considered the actions of a "Reasonable" person, then it is considered entrapment, especially when you have come on this board admitting the only reason you share files is to TRAP kazaa lite users.
So unfortunately your method would not be legal.
Thankyou and good day.
Putting a file up on Kazaa is a lot less passive than just leaving your door unlocked. It's more like putting your TV out on the curb with a sign saying "Take this!'
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote
How could it be given away if it can't get recieved?
Bookmarks