I must agree with T-T's suggestion. *************s is a great example of how to do this. Generally speaking, it is a worthless site used only by traders who put their accounts on trackers at risk by using it. But their tracker reviews are well organized, and for the most part well done (though the reviews aren't as detailed as I would like).

The only part I disagree with is about a template. I support having a suggested template, but especially if it is going to be mod-approved, I see very little cause to hold firmly to a generic outline that may not work well for providing in depth reviews of certain trackers.