could I be an uploader at 0-day sites if...

[anto]

Im with Stoi On this one.
Just because it appeared on your tracker first does not make it yours.

However on a couple of trackers i am a member off i respect the uploaders wishes and leave it as site exclusive - Why upset the uploader and miss out on other great uploads?

true but if they want it left as site exclusive i wouldn't uploaded to a different site

[dunson]

The whole issue here is really whether trackers or uploaders have a right to place copyrights on their content, which is obviously a ridiculous notion on its face.

[fatcat69]

Im with Stoi On this one.
Just because it appeared on your tracker first does not make it yours.

However on a couple of trackers i am a member off i respect the uploaders wishes and leave it as site exclusive - Why upset the uploader and miss out on other great uploads?

true but if they want it left as site exclusive i wouldn't uploaded to a different site

Well tbh, most uploaders upload for more then 1 site. But they will up something on one site before others...for like packs and stuff. Then a day or two later put it on the other site.

[Something Else]

On some sites with specialised content, where uploaders rip things themselves, there is an option to keep the rip exclusive to the tracker. And another to allow it to be shared freely. Seems sensible.
I don't like to see packs with the name of other trackers on them for example you can find:
pack-SCT or pack-FTN on quite a few smaller trackers.

[anto]

On some sites with specialised content, where uploaders rip things themselves, there is an option to keep the rip exclusive to the tracker. And another to allow it to be shared freely. Seems sensible.
I don't like to see packs with the name of other trackers on them for example you can find:
pack-SCT or pack-FTN on quite a few smaller trackers.

seen alot of these on btjunkie

[FatBob]

you can be an uploader in goem if you want to

[myllian]

I don't have scene axx, but i have a bunch of 0-day trackers with good pretimes and when a release hits, I grab it on the first tracker its on and put it on a fast server and up it to another tracker that doesn't have it yet?

A lot of trackers get their stuff from SCT or SCC and don't have axx. It's lame imo because in the end the content is exactly the same on all those sites.

[stoi]

just because its uploaded on those first, doesnt mean the upload of another site steals it from those (if you can call it stealing)

FTP AXX
FTP dumps
Usenet

there are a few places uploaders can get the same release from, not just from another tracker.

[Night0wl]

well sorry anto, but if your doing that with scene releases, you need to be shot.

scene releases should always be left untouched imo

if they are not scene releases, then do what you want lol

I don't really get what you are saying here. Does the scene have some kind of power over what can be done with files that are stolen in the first place?

I'm not an uploader anywhere, but if I was then the files I wouldn't upload anywhere else, packed or unpacked, would be exclusive uploads, which are for the most part rare userrips and have nothing to do with scene in any way. The sites I'm talking about are sites that ask you to follow the uploaders wishes and ask permission before spreading.

[stoi]

well sorry anto, but if your doing that with scene releases, you need to be shot.

scene releases should always be left untouched imo

if they are not scene releases, then do what you want lol

I don't really get what you are saying here. Does the scene have some kind of power over what can be done with files that are stolen in the first place?

I'm not an uploader anywhere, but if I was then the files I wouldn't upload anywhere else, packed or unpacked, would be exclusive uploads, which are for the most part rare userrips and have nothing to do with scene in any way. The sites I'm talking about are sites that ask you to follow the uploaders wishes and ask permission before spreading.

Its just respect to the scene.

Now lets say you download a scene release, unrar it, burn it, 2 years later you re-rip it and re-rar it, then of course you shouldnt say thanks to the scene or name it the scene release.

But if you get a 0 day release, or you download a scene release from 5 years ago and then upload it, you should keep it as is, and name the torrent as such.

I hate seeing a torrent called Halo_XBOX_NTSC.torrent and you look at the files and they are the same files that the scene released years ago.

and why should anyone get permission from anyone, its not yours anymore, and it was never the trackers.

so i would have to get permission from you to share it on emule, kazaa, or even burn a copy for my friend/family.

its a load of crap, once its uploaded, and its snatched, its not yours or the trackers anymore.