Who cares if he makes money from the site? If they're providing a service that people are damn well willing to pay for then why not let them? You're forgetting that no one is making anyone donate to these sites.
Now as far as whether it's good for these trackers or not, it can be very useful in some ways:
1. Those that actually seed will reap the benefits of having a high ratio, therefore being able to download more.
2. Those that choose to hit & run constantly will eventually run out of money and be required to seed or be banned. If they don't run out of money they're still supporting the tracker by paying its bills and maybe putting some extra change in the owner's pockets.
I don't see anything wrong with p2l personally, but it all depends on having a select few who are willing to do some work and upload, without the uploaders we wouldn't have p2l. In my opinion if anything the uploaders should be paid a small amount for their work.
Bookmarks