Homeless Men Beatin Each Other Silly!

[Chevy]

Masterpiece = Starts the thread
Ziggyjuarez = spam
brotherdoobie = spam
MalaDzen spam
Bujub22 = spam
Arcadia = objection to the issue
Filliz = Objection to the issue
Nujub22= Replies
Breda = Makes it a society issue
mortsapprentice = confirms society issue
Jonno Celebs= Objection to the issue
Snny = infight
Arcadia = spam
Snny = bring up a country generalisation issue based on the website's writings
Mastapiece= replies
RGX = "wow, what a society of civlised beings you are."
Withcheese = spam
Bujub= spam
DanB = Realtes issue to boxing
Bujub22 = supportsd sports relationship
WIthcheese = spam
DanB = spam
Tikibonon = agressive towards American generalkiztion
Brenda = Cute reply
mortsapprentice = Antagonism
Tikibonom = BItes into antogonism
Snny = Antogonism
Brenda = realises thread as being generalism (I support that)
lee551 = responds at the earlier generalization
jazzthefunk = meets generalization with a worse case of it
sSnny = Attempts to defend himselfd by general;izing the americans
Tikibonbon = Attempts to distanxchimslef from nationalistic debates
Tikibonbon = Debates nationalistically
Snny = States facts as requestsed
Ziggyjuarez = raises the issue of "what is going on?"
Tikibonbon = OPens up arguament
Snny = makes best post in the thread "we'd be pretty daft if we only cared about the people on our doorstep.
"
ziggyjuarez = Makes a good point reelates to the issue
shn = takes away the generalization aspect of it
BUsyman = defends the issue in that it is relational
RGX = gets into the sub-issue "being [aid"
Snny = Talks again about the issue but defends being gemneralised
Chevy = spams
HObbes = Re=opens up the sub-issue whic is not more [ertinent
RGX = Discusses
mortsapprentice = Attempts to reopen arguament
Brenda = keeps it int he scatal framsework but differing fr ciounrty
Brothervdoobuie = clever spam
Hobbes = contradicts himself many times

Not quite sure why I quoted this but I flet it might be a good exercise to go through the thread like this. I thought it would take a minute but it didn't so therfore I am not going to correct all the spellling mistakes etc... and I may have appraised posts differently than if I had reread.

nb = spam is never made out ot be negative

[mortsapprentice]

Originally posted by Chevy@27 April 2004 - 16:50

Masterpiece = Starts the thread
Ziggyjuarez = spam
brotherdoobie = spam
MalaDzen spam
Bujub22 = spam
Arcadia = objection to the issue
Filliz = Objection to the issue
Nujub22= Replies
Breda = Makes it a society issue
mortsapprentice = confirms society issue
Jonno Celebs= Objection to the issue
Snny = infight
Arcadia = spam
Snny = bring up a country generalisation issue based on the website's writings
Mastapiece= replies
RGX = "wow, what a society of civlised beings you are."
Withcheese = spam
Bujub= spam
DanB = Realtes issue to boxing
Bujub22 = supportsd sports relationship
WIthcheese = spam
DanB = spam
Tikibonon = agressive towards American generalkiztion
Brenda = Cute reply
mortsapprentice = Antagonism
Tikibonom = BItes into antogonism
Snny = Antogonism
Brenda = realises thread as being generalism (I support that)
lee551 = responds at the earlier generalization
jazzthefunk = meets generalization with a worse case of it
sSnny = Attempts to defend himselfd by general;izing the americans
Tikibonbon = Attempts to distanxchimslef from nationalistic debates
Tikibonbon = Debates nationalistically
Snny = States facts as requestsed
Ziggyjuarez = raises the issue of "what is going on?"
Tikibonbon = OPens up arguament
Snny = makes best post in the thread "we'd be pretty daft if we only cared about the people on our doorstep.
"
ziggyjuarez = Makes a good point reelates to the issue
shn = takes away the generalization aspect of it
BUsyman = defends the issue in that it is relational
RGX = gets into the sub-issue "being [aid"
Snny = Talks again about the issue but defends being gemneralised
Chevy = spams
HObbes = Re=opens up the sub-issue whic is not more [ertinent
RGX = Discusses
mortsapprentice = Attempts to reopen arguament
Brenda = keeps it int he scatal framsework but differing fr ciounrty
Brothervdoobuie = clever spam
Hobbes = contradicts himself many times

Not quite sure why I quoted this but I flet it might be a good exercise to go through the thread like this. I thought it would take a minute but it didn't so therfore I am not going to correct all the spellling mistakes etc... and I may have appraised posts differently than if I had reread.

nb = spam is never made out ot be negative

nicely done

didnt realise i was tryin to reopen the argument though

[bujub22]

[QUOTE]
Masterpiece = Starts the thread
Ziggyjuarez = spam
brotherdoobie = spam
MalaDzen spam
Bujub22 = spam
Arcadia = objection to the issue
Filliz = Objection to the issue
Nujub22= Replies
Breda = Makes it a society issue
mortsapprentice = confirms society issue
Jonno Celebs= Objection to the issue
Snny = infight
Arcadia = spam
Snny = bring up a country generalisation issue based on the website's writings
Mastapiece= replies
RGX = "wow, what a society of civlised beings you are."
Withcheese = spam
Bujub= spam
DanB = Realtes issue to boxing
Bujub22 = supportsd sports relationship
WIthcheese = spam
DanB = spam
Tikibonon = agressive towards American generalkiztion
Brenda = Cute reply
mortsapprentice = Antagonism
Tikibonom = BItes into antogonism
Snny = Antogonism
Brenda = realises thread as being generalism (I support that)
lee551 = responds at the earlier generalization
jazzthefunk = meets generalization with a worse case of it
sSnny = Attempts to defend himselfd by general;izing the americans
Tikibonbon = Attempts to distanxchimslef from nationalistic debates
Tikibonbon = Debates nationalistically
Snny = States facts as requestsed
Ziggyjuarez = raises the issue of "what is going on?"
Tikibonbon = OPens up arguament
Snny = makes best post in the thread "we'd be pretty daft if we only cared about the people on our doorstep.
"
ziggyjuarez = Makes a good point reelates to the issue
shn = takes away the generalization aspect of it
BUsyman = defends the issue in that it is relational
RGX = gets into the sub-issue "being [aid"
Snny = Talks again about the issue but defends being gemneralised
Chevy = spams
HObbes = Re=opens up the sub-issue whic is not more [ertinent
RGX = Discusses
mortsapprentice = Attempts to reopen arguament
Brenda = keeps it int he scatal framsework but differing fr ciounrty
Brothervdoobuie = clever spam
Hobbes = contradicts himself many times





wow someone took the time to do this :helpsmile:

[hobbes]

Chevy,

What is unclear to you? Stating that someone has contradicted himself is an unsupported accusation.

I made 2 points:

1) Bumfights is just a facet of this jagged rock called exploitation, and yes it occurs in sanctioned sports as well, but it is a little more cleverly disguised. I did mention that if "mentally ill bums" were targeted, the exploitation would indeed be different from the routine exploitation of athletes we see in sanctioned sports. This is not a contradiction, but an attempt to show RGX, that in some cases (the mentally ill) the bums may not have many options to make money and thusly he may be right. Although the mentally ill are highly over-represented in the homeless community, they only comprise 20%, so most bums are just that.

As for the "other" many contradictions, I have no clue what you are on about.

2) A society is not "fucked up" because people make the video. Those people who make it and mainly those who support it are. These are individuals, making personal choices. And I'm sure many orders are coming from outside the US.

I want people to focus their responses on their reaction to the topic, not the country in which it was made.

[brenda]

@ Chevvy = excellent work my friend what a visually beautiful way of reviewing a debate

@ Hobbes = you have my sincere apologies if you felt in any way that i was in any way sweeping you up with the fucked up society

[hobbes]

Originally posted by brenda@27 April 2004 - 18:16
@ Chevvy = excellent work my friend what a visually beautiful way of reviewing a debate

@ Hobbes = you have my sincere apologies if you felt in any way that i was in any way sweeping you up with the fucked up society

Thank you.

[Snee]

Snny = Attempts to defend himself by generalizing the americans

sp fixed

Not quite my intent, I was talking about attitude. Lee said a lot of un-Americans have a certain attitude towards America, and like I said before I don't think it's a one-sided issue.

I didn't mean to stick 'em all in one group, or say that they all did something, in fact, I said it all the way around. The interpreting of my words to encompass all of America was made by the reader.

Having said that, I wasn't being very clear.

EDit: I must admit to having had my judgement somewhat impaired, mainly 'cuz I was annoyed.

I think the whole business of making a generalization about bumfights being "typical american entertainment" was a shitty thing to do. It wasn&#39;t right, and not <s>very</s> funny.

[masterpiece21]

Damn all i started this thread for is to share sumting i thought was funny with others,and it turned out2b many members from different countries defending themselfs and bashin on america sure america nots perfect actually its nowhere near&#33;but we got homeless men beating each other for money already and its gonna continue so why r we argueing ab it? And no mortsapprentice i didnt start this thread to make hell;tho its pretty interesting now

[Mad Cat]

I wrote a very big thread, but anti spam just screwed me over and I can&#39;t be arsed writing it all again.

I disagree with RGX here, I believe that you can&#39;t keep a good man down. I had stuff to back this up, but I can&#39;t be bothered typing it all again.

[brotherdoobie]

Bum Fights... Presents The 2004 Presidential Elections

Bush


Kerry




Peace brotherdoobie