But it's one of those subjective judgement things mate.Originally posted by soopaman@17 October 2003 - 17:47
JPaul,
I get the gist of what you're saying but it doesn't take away the fact that the Thread was closed because of one persons pedantry!!!
I personally don't agree that the thread should have been shut, I have seen a lot worse, however I can't find the now to review it in the cold light of day. As I recall scribblec re-iterated that he really still wanted me to be run over by a lorry, but that could have been somewhere else.
The point is that I have seen things which I have considered worse left open, however the important thing is the I. Lamsey, or any of the mods must make a judgement call. The decision on whether the thread has gone too far is theirs to make, that is why they are there. In addition to keeping the board tidy, moving threads to appropriate places, dealing with spammers and flame attacks etc.
Like I said it is a subjective call, but it is their subjective call which is the important one. There is always the facility to make representations if you disagree with those calls.
Bookmarks