Fish in Soup

[tesco]

Important question:

Can fish live in soup?:unsure:
I mean, can they breathe in it?:unsure:

[zapjb]

I'd bet on a saltwater catfish or a shark.

[killer23]

from my own reasoning-

no, fish need oxygen, however some fish are more tolerant of low-oxygen water,
soup has a very low percentage of oxygen depending on the recipe, soup is thick therefore making it hard for the fish to breathe out of its gills, thus making it extremly difficult for the fish to swim, so the answer is no. :)

[Hairbautt]

Just what is 'important' about this question?

[killer23]

Just what is 'important' about this question?

nothing is important in the lounge anyway:)

[Defy]

Me thinks someone won a goldfish at the local carnival and "in the name of science" conducted an experiment. :(

Think/do first, ask questions later. ;)

[Something Else]

http://img216.imageshack.us/img216/7356/yawnnn9.gif (http://imageshack.us)

[killer23]

http://img216.imageshack.us/img216/7356/yawnnn9.gif (http://imageshack.us)

lame posts again :lol:

[Something Else]

http://img291.imageshack.us/img291/6776/zombiefq3.gif (http://imageshack.us)

[snowultra]

i bet those goldfish crackers can stay alive in soup.

[tesco]

from my own reasoning-

no, fish need oxygen, however some fish are more tolerant of low-oxygen water,
soup has a very low percentage of oxygen depending on the recipe, soup is thick therefore making it hard for the fish to breathe out of its gills, thus making it extremly difficult for the fish to swim, so the answer is no. :)I'm talking something with a lot of water.
Just for simplicity's sake we'll say Lipton chicken noodle.

[Sextent]

Yes, some can, in some types of soup.

You would have to be more specific about the actual soup you want the fish to live in and indeed the species of fish. How long you would want it to live for may also be a good idea.

[optimus_prime]

Important question:

Can fish live in soup?:unsure:
I mean, can they breathe in it?:unsure:

not if you cook it right :)

[JazzyJeff]

Would be handy if your going on holiday, just leave the fish in a pot of noodle soup and you won't have to pay the neighbours kids to feed em.

[thewizeard]

If you use a clear soup.. and keep the temperature around 24 degrees ( Celsius) connect an air block with an air pump )..if would probably live there quite happily...till you finish the soup of course..

[zapjb]

Depends on the salt. And the fish's salt tolerance. Most soup is heavily salted.

[game1283]

Just what is 'important' about this question?

If you have no aquarium or at least a bowl.. then you can use your soup as temporary habitat for your fish..

:)