TheMusicMan
09-22-2003, 06:05 PM
The companies
Warner Bros. -•- Universal Music Studios -•- BMG München -•- BMG Berlin -•- EMI Musik Group
did sue a 36 year old guy from germany because he was an active board user at www.mp3network.to
The problem in this case was that this board user had the same nickname like a well known uploader. The court did decide that this is reason enough to sue him.
For now he has to pay 20.000 Euro (Euro and Dollar are nearly a 1:1 calculation - it's a bit less at the moment) but EMI wants to sue this guy (300.000 Euro this time) because he did not sign some document that he won't do it again (remember that he did not upload it but the court did say that it is enough reason to sue him if the court believes that he is responsible - EMI doesn't have to prove it !)
How did they find this guy ?
Like I posted before: He was a board user and had some avatars linked to his domain name plus he has his real birthday in his board profile - that was enough information to "get him".
If you understand german you can visit http://www.mp3-streit.de/ to learn more about this case.
I think it is not the correct way to sue a user just because he has the same nickname like a well known uploader.
What do you think about this ?
Greetings
Warner Bros. -•- Universal Music Studios -•- BMG München -•- BMG Berlin -•- EMI Musik Group
did sue a 36 year old guy from germany because he was an active board user at www.mp3network.to
The problem in this case was that this board user had the same nickname like a well known uploader. The court did decide that this is reason enough to sue him.
For now he has to pay 20.000 Euro (Euro and Dollar are nearly a 1:1 calculation - it's a bit less at the moment) but EMI wants to sue this guy (300.000 Euro this time) because he did not sign some document that he won't do it again (remember that he did not upload it but the court did say that it is enough reason to sue him if the court believes that he is responsible - EMI doesn't have to prove it !)
How did they find this guy ?
Like I posted before: He was a board user and had some avatars linked to his domain name plus he has his real birthday in his board profile - that was enough information to "get him".
If you understand german you can visit http://www.mp3-streit.de/ to learn more about this case.
I think it is not the correct way to sue a user just because he has the same nickname like a well known uploader.
What do you think about this ?
Greetings