Which is higher quality?

[Bebi]

Which is higher quality.. a commercially made 4.5gb dvd or a dvd that has been created with convertxtodvd from a 720p blu-ray rip?

[TONiC]

I'm gunna say 4.5 gbyte DVD, rather than the 720p blu-ray rip on the grounds of a lossy conversion, but I'm sure there are those willing to argue.

Either way I'm also sure you won't notice the difference.

[Edit]
Just realised the source files for a DVD and BluRay (both commercially speaking) will still be the same film real, so there would be no quality gained...

[QPD]

i'd go on 720p...but there are a lot of other aspects to be consider.

Source, audio, codecs an so on

[{I}{K}{E}]

If the rip is done the proper way, 720p quality will be better

[homoloordi]

I think 720p. I converted one movie with converxtodvd and burned to dvd and quality was really good!