Lord Of The Rings:return Of The King

[DKRiceEater]

hi,

what would you rate the third movie of "Lord Of The Rings"
?

rate it 1-5

also tell me why you liked it or disliked it

[ForbiddenDNA]

Originally posted by DKRiceEater@24 December 2003 - 23:04
hi,

what would you rate the third movie of "Lord Of The Rings"
?

rate it 1-5

also tell me why you liked it or disliked it
5/5

<_<

[Rock Tonic Juice Magic]

How bout greatest movie ever up to this point in time

:lol:

[berserkerbin]

4.8 ... only because the book is 5/5, and this was missing some of the stuff from the book (the Grey Company, Aragorn looking in the Palantir *voluntarily*, Saruman, Imrahil, Beregond, the Houses of Healing, Eowyn & Faramir, the Scouring of the Shire {can see why they had to miss that one})... we&#39;ll see about the EE DVD (should have *at least* Saruman, the Houses of Healing, Eowyn & Faramir, or so I hear) ... :D

BTW: a great tolkien site: TheOneRing.net (http://www.theonering.net)

[ForbiddenDNA]

Originally posted by berserkerbin@24 December 2003 - 23:16
4.8 ... only because the book is 5/5, and this was missing some of the stuff from the book (the Grey Company, Aragorn looking in the Palantir *voluntarily*, Saruman, Imrahil, Beregond, the Houses of Healing, Eowyn & Faramir, the Scouring of the Shire {can see why they had to miss that one})... we&#39;ll see about the EE DVD (should have *at least* Saruman, the Houses of Healing, Eowyn & Faramir, or so I hear) ... :D

BTW: a great tolkien site: TheOneRing.net (http://www.theonering.net)
BE PATIENT DUANE&#33;&#33;&#33; PATIENTS&#33;&#33;&#33; :01:

[Monkeee]

5/5 overall the movie owned :D

[wenze1]

3/5 Not my type of movie but I watched it and it&#39;s alright. :rolleyes: :dog:

[xevanescencex]

4.99999999999999.../5

hehehe, the book kinda ruined it for me...did anyone else get fooled when the screen during the end went completely blank for a couple of seconds or blacked out several times? everyone was like, "what?&#33;?&#33;" :lol:

[Guillaume]

2.5/5
Visually magnificent, but I&#39;m a Tolkien-integrist, so... ;)

[CanYouDigItSucka]

5/5

Considering beforehand i knew that certain bits had been cut i still came away thinking i&#39;d just watched the best film of the year in my opinion.....now i know the dvd will be even better, with all the cuts from the book inserted...

[Chame1eon]

4/5 Just because the other ones were better and the movie seemed to end about 6 times. It also seemed kind unbelivable that nothing really bad happend to the main charachters. The whole trilogy was still one of the best movies i&#39;ve seen in a while though

[supersaiyanvegeta85]

10/5
if possible? go figure how much i like this movie

[Rock Tonic Juice Magic]

Originally posted by Chame1eon@25 December 2003 - 11:48
4/5 Just because the other ones were better and the movie seemed to end about 6 times. It also seemed kind unbelivable that nothing really bad happend to the main charachters. The whole trilogy was still one of the best movies i&#39;ve seen in a while though
how did it end 6 times? i only saw one ending.

[abu_has_the_power]

Originally posted by supersaiyanvegeta85@25 December 2003 - 16:22
10/5
if possible? go figure how much i like this movie
i go with 1000000/5. amazing movie. saw it in toronto. crazy&#33;&#33; legolas kills the elephant. that was amazing. i didn&#39;t read the books, so i don&#39;t really care if they took out parts. still a great movie. made me cry too. :cry1:

[Stonecoldfreak1]

2/5

[chalice]

17/5.

I would have given it 18/5 but my 8 key isn&#39;t working.

[Tegamal]

4.9/5

EE DVD will be 5/5, no doubt&#33; I read the books, pissed & moaned about the Scouring of the Shire for most of 2003, so it was out of my system when I saw it in the theaters. Awesome movie, all the "endings" were great. I will admit I cried at the end.

[berserkerbin]

4/5 Just because the other ones were better and the movie seemed to end about 6 times. It also seemed kind unbelivable that nothing really bad happend to the main charachters. The whole trilogy was still one of the best movies i&#39;ve seen in a while though










[BEWARE, SPOILERS BELOW ....]























Theoden and Gollum DIED, Frodo, Bilbo, Gandalf and the Elves had to leave Middle Earth (Elrond, never gets to see his daughter again), Denethor became an over-cooked human marshmallow (worst done character in the movie&#33;), Faramir had to see his dad do an impression of an over-cooked human marshmallow ...

Never the less, I do agree with you ... the movie did have a somewhat unrealistic tone at the end ...

[Rock Tonic Juice Magic]

Originally posted by Tegamal@25 December 2003 - 16:55
4.9/5

EE DVD will be 5/5, no doubt&#33; I read the books, pissed & moaned about the Scouring of the Shire for most of 2003, so it was out of my system when I saw it in the theaters. Awesome movie, all the "endings" were great. I will admit I cried at the end.
ya anyways the scorning of the shire would have pissed alot of people off. because we just finsished like a 2hr battle i wouldnt really wanna see another one. anyways i hear the ee dvd is going to be 5+ hrs. so cool. B)

[Baazigar]

5/5 Even though I wasn&#39;t a big fan of the LOTR books I did like the movies,I even purchsed the first two dvds.When I watched the final episode it was mind blowing I can&#39;t wait for it to come on dvd with all the edited scenes. :D

[Chame1eon]

Originally posted by Rock Tonic Juice Magic@25 December 2003 - 15:52

how did it end 6 times? i only saw one ending.
I was just exaggerating, but i mean it almost seemed to end several times when they were on the rocks, when frodo was leaving on the ship, when sam got married, ect, and because of my state of mind at the time i wanted it to.

[L0rD_S0tH]

I give it a solid 5/5. I loved the books and I love the movies.

[bootylicious]

4.9/5...it was awesome&#33; a bit slow here and there but was unlike any adventure movie i had seen in a long time. i already have the first two EE and counting the dayz till the EE comes out for this one. :)

[MuGen_PoWeR]

i rate this movie -5/5 :lol: :lol: