Holy shit, Sin City got 3 1/2 Stars from major critic :o

[Formula1]

http://critics.com/s/sincity.htm

The person that gave it one star is an asshole.

[{I}{K}{E}]

I don't look @ those stats. IMDb has a much better rating sytem if you wanna know if its a good movie or not, or just check the trailer ;)

[Formula1]

Yeah, i definetely go with imdb when thinking of seeing a movie. But aprt from that Roger Ebert's critique is the best out of the other major critics.

[3RA1N1AC]

i prefer www.rottentomatoes.com 'cause it uses a larger sample to figure its average, and includes blurbs from most of 'um. includes not only a larger number of mainstream reviews, but also some critics from indie & genre websites so there's a bit more variety to the opinions.

http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/sin_city/

key: red tomato = positive, green splat = negative. :P

[BoB!1!]

is sin city that thing on bravo or men and mottors. or summit. where that guy walks around the city walking into strip clubs and fetish houses. and talks about it?

[Adster]

looks awesome actually Quentin Tarininto apparently directed a scene which we will all argue about what scene he directed for years!

[Busyman]

I go by previews only.

Fuck critics. :dry:

[Adster]

I go by previews only.

Fuck critics. :dry:

shouldn't you go by the movie?? you know actually watch it

when you buy a car do you go by the commercial?? or do you guy by what the car dealer says

[Busyman]

shouldn't you go by the movie?? you know actually watch it

when you buy a car do you go by the commercial?? or do you guy by what the car dealer says
I can't watch the movie before I watch it. :blink:

A good preview = me seeing the motherfucker at the theater when it's released :wacko:

[Adster]

ok fair enough

Just that sometimes some previews can be miss leading look at Alexander the trailer they showed looked kick ass in the trailer they only showed bits of the 2 battle scenes/

the movie was just Alexander the shit 3 hrs and about 20 mins of it was battle scenes

[3RA1N1AC]

I go by previews only.

Fuck critics. :dry:
dude, trailers? you ever go see a comedy 'cause the trailer was so great, and then realize that the movie only has 3 good jokes and they were all in the trailer?

ALSO: this guy. (http://www.abc.net.au/thingo/txt/s1123910.htm) the voice. "thunder throat." the one in all of the trailers. video is a few minutes long, totally worth watching.

[Busyman]

dude, trailers? trailers are so friggin' deceptive. it's the art of making bad movies look good. like when you go see a comedy 'cause the trailer was so great, and then realize that the movie only has 3 good jokes and they were all in the trailer.

ALSO: this guy. (http://www.abc.net.au/thingo/txt/s1123910.htm) the voice. the one in all of the trailers. video is a few minutes long, totally worth watching.
I gotcha but what you may get from a trailer and what I get from one is probably different.

I don't go to the theater often anymore and now that it's Spring time I see 3 movies at the drive-in for 9 bucks and I can sleep through the shit ones (sometimes there's one I won't care for)

For me to go see a movie at a regular theater it usually has to seem REEEALLY good by the preview or is something I already wanted to see.

Example: Star Wars Episode III, Sin City, Batman,..etc

EVERYONE knows trailers can fool you...

....but so can stuffy bitch ass critics. Most of them suck. :dry:

[3RA1N1AC]

yeah point taken. some people just don't like reading reviews, or think analyzing entertainment takes all the joy out of it. personally i think most reviewers aren't too good, but i do enjoy it when a reviewer knows how to write well and actually has good insightful comments to make.

i guess my problem with trailers (and why i don't find them very reliable) is not only that they can make bad movies look good or good movies look bad, but oftentimes they misrepresent what the movie is about. a trailer can make a movie look as if it's about one thing, when it's really about something completely different.

edit: having said that... of course professional reviewers aren't the be-all & end-all. i'm sure everyone has at least one favorite movie that's been widely trashed by both reviewers and fans.

[Busyman]

yeah point taken. some people just don't like reading reviews, or think analyzing entertainment takes all the joy out of it. personally i think most reviewers aren't too good, but i do enjoy it when a reviewer knows how to write well and actually has good insightful comments to make.

i guess my problem with trailers (and why i don't find them very reliable) is not only that they can make bad movies look good or good movies look bad, but oftentimes they misrepresent what the movie is about. a trailer can make a movie look as if it's about one thing, when it's really about something completely different.

edit: having said that... of course professional reviewers aren't the be-all & end-all. i'm sure everyone has at least one favorite movie that's been widely trashed by both reviewers and fans.
One thing I hate about some trailers is that they give away too much of the movie.
I figure out alot from many trailers.

[SingaBoiy]

is sin city that thing on bravo or men and mottors. or summit. where that guy walks around the city walking into strip clubs and fetish houses. and talks about it?
I think you are thinking of the one on Comedy Central. Insomniac.

[100%]

New York Times

By MANOHLA DARGIS
Published: April 1, 2005
"Sin City" has been made with such scrupulous care and obvious love for its genre influences that it's a shame the movie is kind of a bore.