• Student Suspended for Calling Teacher Fat on Facebook

    A California high school student has been suspended for making rude remarks about a teacher on Facebook.
    For the more old-fashioned disciplinarians among us, this might seem like common sense; however, the ACLU is claiming the student’s free speech rights were violated and says the school broke federal and state laws.

    In a letter to Mesa Verde High School Principal Rick Messer, an ACLU staff attorney said that tenth-grader Donny Tobolski’s Facebook post was “protected under the state and federal constitutions as well as the Education Code.”
    The comment in question, which was written after Tobolski was assigned an unusually large amount of biology homework, stated that the boy’s teacher was a “fat ass who should stop eating fast food, and is a douche bag.” The message was posted from Tobolski’s home computer and not during school hours.
    In a similar case from last November, a federal agency declared that Facebook updates are, in fact, protected speech. In that situation, an employee named Dawnmarie Souza was fired for making derogatory remarks about a supervisor in a Facebook status update.

    In both cases, though the complaining parties were rude and vulgar, the speech wasn’t necessarily threatening.
    Souza’s hearing is expected to turn into a lengthy legal battle. We’ll follow that case as well as this one to see where Facebook stands in the realm of free and protected speech.

    Source: Mashable
    Comments 13 Comments
    1. Tarom's Avatar
      Tarom -
      Futuristic Sex Robotz!
    1. cibu's Avatar
      cibu -
      That just shows you that you should stop writting all tne crap you think of on Facebook .
    1. iLOVENZB's Avatar
      iLOVENZB -
      http://twitter.com/
    1. bijoy's Avatar
      bijoy -
      he should have learnt how to use vpn or proxies before posting....

      Quote Originally Posted by ilovenzb View Post

      lol...:d
    1. brilman's Avatar
      brilman -
      Yes he was a dumb ass for posting But still if I posted that my boss is a fat pig that's my opinion. Whats next getting fired or suspended for thinking out of the box
    1. sandman_1's Avatar
      sandman_1 -
      Quote Originally Posted by brilman View Post
      Yes he was a dumb ass for posting But still if I posted that my boss is a fat pig that's my opinion. Whats next getting fired or suspended for thinking out of the box
      Free speech is pretty much regarding the government trying to suppress what you say. A private business doesn't have to follow that rule. The business where my wife works fired someone awhile back. One of her friends that still worked there made some derogatory comments about one of the owners of the place and about firing her friend on Facebook. She was also fired for her comments. The woman had the right to say what she said, but her boss also had the right to fire her too.
      Sucks but that is how it is.

      Freedom of speech doesn't mean freedom from consequences of saying what you want.
    1. proforma's Avatar
      proforma -
      Did the teacher stop eating fast food?
    1. brilman's Avatar
      brilman -
      Free speech is pretty much regarding the government trying to suppress what you say. A private business doesn't have to follow that rule. The business where my wife works fired someone awhile back. One of her friends that still worked there made some derogatory comments about one of the owners of the place and about firing her friend on Facebook. She was also fired for her comments. The woman had the right to say what she said, but her boss also had the right to fire her too.
      Sucks but that is how it is.

      Freedom of speech doesn't mean freedom from consequences of saying what you want.
      Understand that you can be fired for anything but I would think a school would fall under diff. rules
    1. sandman_1's Avatar
      sandman_1 -
      Quote Originally Posted by brilman View Post
      [

      Understand that you can be fired for anything but I would think a school would fall under diff. rules
      Try throwing some colorful expletives at a teacher. I know from my experience, when I was a trouble making teenager, I usually got In-School-Suspension. You can say it but it doesn't mean you get to say it free from consequences. However I would say most teachers, if you are civil and mature, will let you plead your case if you do take offense to something of their making.
    1. rdtphd's Avatar
      rdtphd -
      Quote Originally Posted by proforma View Post
      Did the teacher stop eating fast food?
      my thoughts exactly. We don't know enough about the teacher maybe all of the statement is 100% factual.
    1. brilman's Avatar
      brilman -
      Gonna put a disclaimer on my status that reads something about "might of been drunk at time of post"
    1. EyeCandy's Avatar
      EyeCandy -
      Public Schools are not the same as businesses...its free speech

      http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/us_facebook_firing
    1. OldIronTits's Avatar
      OldIronTits -
      Quote Originally Posted by proforma View Post
      Did the teacher stop eating fast food?
      +1


      (and the question of douchebaggery)