Re: Saddam sentenced to death
I was wondering how the members who disagreed with capital punishment feel about Saddams sentence.
Funny how Hirohito was allowed to live after WWII.:whistling
Just stirring it.:lol:
Re: Saddam sentenced to death
Quote:
Originally Posted by
bigboab
Funny how Hirohito was allowed to live after WWII.:whistling
That was all MacArthur's idea; he thought it would humanize Hirohito to the Japanese hoi polloi and make them more amenable to his plan.
I don't hold any brief for executing Saddam, but hey, give the Iraqis what they want, it's fine with me. ;)
Re: Saddam sentenced to death
It's strange that, following delay after interminable delay they suddenly come up with a verdict and judgement with hardly a pause for breath.
Anyone would think there was an election in the offing.
Re: Saddam sentenced to death
I am against death penalty.
Re: Saddam sentenced to death
If only we had some Iraqi opinions.
Re: Saddam sentenced to death
Quote:
Originally Posted by
j2k4
Quote:
Originally Posted by
bigboab
Funny how Hirohito was allowed to live after WWII.:whistling
That was all MacArthur's idea; he thought it would humanize Hirohito to the Japanese hoi polloi and make them more amenable to his plan.
I don't hold any brief for executing Saddam, but hey, give the Iraqis what they want, it's fine with me. ;)
The Japanese refused to surrender unless their Emperor was not put on trial.
Nothing to do with McArthur, except ceding to their request. Do not argue J2, I dont want to start digging out my diaries.:lol:
Re: Saddam sentenced to death
Quote:
Originally Posted by
bigboab
Quote:
Originally Posted by
j2k4
That was all MacArthur's idea; he thought it would humanize Hirohito to the Japanese hoi polloi and make them more amenable to his plan.
I don't hold any brief for executing Saddam, but hey, give the Iraqis what they want, it's fine with me. ;)
The Japanese refused to surrender unless their Emperor was not put on trial.
Nothing to do with McArthur, except ceding to their request. Do not argue J2, I dont want to start digging out my diaries.:lol:
No, upon further reflection, you are as correct as I am...as I recall, Eisenhower wanted to keel-haul Hirohito, but MacArthur decided to grant the Japanese wish to secure 1) their cooperation, and 2) to demystify Hirohito over time.
And, as you know, MacArthur loved to jab Ike.
Some "mortal" statements were elicited from Hirohito for public consumption subsequently, I believe...my memory is a tad hazy, as MacArthur was a terribly dense subject...he was so terribly self-absorbed, you know. :huh:
Re: Saddam sentenced to death
Quote:
Originally Posted by
j2k4
Quote:
Originally Posted by
bigboab
The Japanese refused to surrender unless their Emperor was not put on trial.
Nothing to do with McArthur, except ceding to their request. Do not argue J2, I dont want to start digging out my diaries.:lol:
No, upon further reflection, you are as correct as I am...as I recall, Eisenhower wanted to keel-haul Hirohito, but MacArthur decided to grant the Japanese wish to secure 1) their cooperation, and 2) to demystify Hirohito over time.
And, as you know, MacArthur loved to jab Ike.
Some "mortal" statements were elicited from Hirohito for public consumption subsequently, I believe...my memory is a tad hazy, as MacArthur was a terribly dense subject...he was so terribly self-absorbed, you know. :huh:
A wee bit off thread.:) I have seen Eisenhower twice. He was staying at Culzean Castle in Scotland. My elder brothers worked in the Culzean Estate and did the 'beating' for him when he was out shooting. We have a photo somewhere in the family with his autograph. I was at school at nearby Maybole and we were 'trooped' down to the local town hall to see him receive the Freedom Of The Town. He never mentioned to me that he knew you.:whistling
Re: Saddam sentenced to death
Quote:
Originally Posted by
lynx
It's strange that, following delay after interminable delay they suddenly come up with a verdict and judgement with hardly a pause for breath.
Anyone would think there was an election in the offing.
As I said before, if the Repubs win then it's a fixed election.
It would basically tell the Republicans that they can do fuck all wrong and still stay in office.
Re: Saddam sentenced to death
Government sanctioned killing in order to emphasize that killing is wrong seems contradictory to me.