Re: Scottish Executive Elections
Re: Scottish Executive Elections
Quote:
Originally Posted by
vidcc
What do you think is worse, an uninformed vote or no vote at all?
I vote for the uninformed vote being the worse of the two.
Under-informed is just as bad.
That said, I hope you get what/who you want.
Re: Scottish Executive Elections
I prefer democracy to include as many people as possible. In an ideal World we would have a 100% turnout.
The next stage would be for people to think more deeply about who they were voting for. However let's not shoot for the moon just now. If we can just get them off their arses for a wee while to go to the bother of choosing their own leaders that's a starting point.
Correct me if I'm wrong but in Australia voting is compulsory. I like that idea.
Re: Scottish Executive Elections
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Mr JP Fugley
I prefer democracy to include as many people as possible. In an ideal World we would have a 100% turnout.
The next stage would be for people to think more deeply about who they were voting for. However let's not shoot for the moon just now. If we can just get them off their arses for a wee while to go to the bother of choosing their own leaders that's a starting point.
Correct me if I'm wrong but in Australia voting is compulsory. I like that idea.
I wouldn't mind it myself, as long as it included concurrent means-testing.
Make 'em show up for the the test, then make the vote optional for those who pass.
They'd figure it out after a few election cycles.
EDIT:
And make it a county, state, or federal holiday to suit.
Re: Scottish Executive Elections
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Mr JP Fugley
I prefer democracy to include as many people as possible. In an ideal World we would have a 100% turnout.
The next stage would be for people to think more deeply about who they were voting for. However let's not shoot for the moon just now. If we can just get them off their arses for a wee while to go to the bother of choosing their own leaders that's a starting point.
Correct me if I'm wrong but in Australia voting is compulsory. I like that idea.
The only way I would find compulsory voting remotely acceptable is if "none of the above" or similar wording were an option.
Some people don't vote because there is no acceptable choice for them.
Re: Scottish Executive Elections
Quote:
Originally Posted by
vidcc
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Mr JP Fugley
I prefer democracy to include as many people as possible. In an ideal World we would have a 100% turnout.
The next stage would be for people to think more deeply about who they were voting for. However let's not shoot for the moon just now. If we can just get them off their arses for a wee while to go to the bother of choosing their own leaders that's a starting point.
Correct me if I'm wrong but in Australia voting is compulsory. I like that idea.
The only way I would find compulsory voting remotely acceptable is if "none of the above" or similar wording were an option.
Some people don't vote because there is no acceptable choice for them.
A quibble easily dealt with by adding that option.
You don't have to get your knickers in a twist over it.
Re: Scottish Executive Elections
Quote:
Originally Posted by
j2k4
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Mr JP Fugley
I prefer democracy to include as many people as possible. In an ideal World we would have a 100% turnout.
The next stage would be for people to think more deeply about who they were voting for. However let's not shoot for the moon just now. If we can just get them off their arses for a wee while to go to the bother of choosing their own leaders that's a starting point.
Correct me if I'm wrong but in Australia voting is compulsory. I like that idea.
I wouldn't mind it myself, as long as it included concurrent means-testing.
Make 'em show up for the the test, then make the vote optional for those who pass.
They'd figure it out after a few election cycles.
EDIT:
And make it a county, state, or federal holiday to suit.
Please explain that to me because my first reading of it and understanding of what you mean is appalling.
Re: Scottish Executive Elections
Predicted turnout around 60%, whilst not great it's a decent improvement on the last time which was around 50%.
That makes me happy, with reservations.
Re: Scottish Executive Elections
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Mr JP Fugley
Quote:
Originally Posted by
j2k4
I wouldn't mind it myself, as long as it included concurrent means-testing.
Make 'em show up for the the test, then make the vote optional for those who pass.
They'd figure it out after a few election cycles.
EDIT:
And make it a county, state, or federal holiday to suit.
Please explain that to me because my first reading of it and understanding of what you mean is appalling.
I'd prefer an informed voter, and means-testing would serve the same function as a naturalization test does in the case of an immigrant.
No reason to be appalled, JP.
Re: Scottish Executive Elections
What do you mean by "means testing".
In my country it refers to income.