is magic dvd ripper better than dvd shrink?

I used CCE with FilmMaker and I must say it did seem cleaner just a tad...

I have DVD Shrink and Nero 6.
Works like a charm! Plus DVDShrink automaticly burns that stuff after you encode it..major time saver! All you do is configure..or backup if it already fits (the first dvd movies around are 4.5gb sometimes)