Star Wars vs Lord of the Rings?

I would have to say that the original Star Wars is better than LOTR. By a long margin. It redefined a genre (almost created one), it was innovative. And the characters are much denser than the LOTR ones.

With that said, if Lucas didnt make the 2nd trilogy (or the 1st as you prefer), nothing much would have been lost.

" L.O.T.R. "

I never liked star wars either and lotr is one of my favs anyway.

so the decision here is not difficult for me:

LOTR

....and how old are all these LOTR lovers?:smilie4:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Busyman™

....and how old are all these LOTR lovers?:smilie4:

---

i am 20 :huh: but why u r asking ?

I think star wars is better

Star Wars is best

This discussion is blasphemy.

The two are not comparable.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by damanebp

This discussion is blasphemy.

The two are not comparable.

---

and which one is better in your opinion ?? :shifty:

as far as movies go star wars 4-6 beats LOTR but the LOTR books are better than any movie could be imo.