http://www.klboard.ath.cx/index.php?...pic=74891&st=0
Why isn't this kind of thing covered in the forum rules? <_<
Why wasn't something done about the flamer?
Please do something about this before it happens again.
Printable View
http://www.klboard.ath.cx/index.php?...pic=74891&st=0
Why isn't this kind of thing covered in the forum rules? <_<
Why wasn't something done about the flamer?
Please do something about this before it happens again.
i've complained about racism numerous times, it seems to be taken rather lightly though...
It was covered in the rules, we recently did an update to them and it was missed in the newest version. I'll bring it up in team chat.
Racism should never be taken lightly.
Thankyou NikkiD. ^_^
It isnt taken lightly, and more happens than members realise, behind the scenes...
things may go on 'behind the scenes' however, if they have no effect to what the normal members see, are they worth doing?Quote:
Originally posted by Rat Faced@18 October 2003 - 23:19
It isnt taken lightly, and more happens than members realise, behind the scenes...
i've complained a few times in the past (though due to my deleting frenzy as amphoteric88, i can't find them now) and seemingly nothing was done
Believe me, things get done. Anyone in Soulseek's KLF MusicWorld last night will tell you ;)
edit: or tonight, for that matter <_<
Well, thats all very well and good for Soulseek's KLF MusicWorld...
Going by your above statement Lamsey, I get the impression that some mods may be spreading themselves a bit thin.
No disrespect intended, but while the aformentioned flaming was happening, there wasn't a single mod to be seen anywhere. :(
We can't be everywhere at every time. We have to watch a lot of people and don't always have a lot of time to dedicate to that.Quote:
Originally posted by Justsomeguy@18 October 2003 - 23:54
Well, thats all very well and good for Soulseek's KLF MusicWorld...
Going by your above statement Lamsey, I get the impression that some mods may be spreading themselves a bit thin.
No disrespect intended, but while the aformentioned flaming was happening, there wasn't a single mod to be seen anywhere. :(
You'd be amazed at the amount we do clean up - our philosophy is to moderate the board silently - if we're doing our job right, you shouldn't even notice we're here.
Soulseek is a good example - I was stopping a potential flamewar before it reached the board.
We can't be everywhere at every time. We have to watch a lot of people and don't always have a lot of time to dedicate to that.Quote:
Originally posted by Lamsey+19 October 2003 - 09:52--></div><table border='0' align='center' width='95%' cellpadding='3' cellspacing='1'><tr><td>QUOTE (Lamsey @ 19 October 2003 - 09:52)</td></tr><tr><td id='QUOTE'> <!--QuoteBegin-Justsomeguy@18 October 2003 - 23:54
Well, thats all very well and good for Soulseek's KLF MusicWorld...
Going by your above statement Lamsey, I get the impression that some mods may be spreading themselves a bit thin.
No disrespect intended, but while the aformentioned flaming was happening, there wasn't a single mod to be seen anywhere. :(
You'd be amazed at the amount we do clean up - our philosophy is to moderate the board silently - if we're doing our job right, you shouldn't even notice we're here.
Soulseek is a good example - I was stopping a potential flamewar before it reached the board. [/b][/quote]
I don't expect you guys to be everywhere.. that would be unrealistic and unreasonable.
I'm just saying that things may have been a bit different if there had been just one mod's name lit up in the online member's list at the time.
I'm sure that if there had been a mod online, that topic would'nt have gotten out of hand. In my experience, people usually behave better when they know the authorities are about.
But when the cats away... :ph34r:
Yes that thread pissed me off as for klf Musicworld I dont know what happened in there coz I dont go in that kidie room anymore
It seems rather strange, to me, to expect our board mods to moderate other KL-related areas. SoulSeek would be an excellent example of that.
:ninja:
We dont.
The board has no authority at either soulseek or IRC (p2pchat)
However, like other people..........just because we are active here, does not mean we dont have interests elsewhere.
If these interests overlap, then thats not unusual....epecially as the board members opened IRC rooms and soulseek rooms with open invitations...
I didn't see the particular thread you are speaking about.
However I did comment when the new rules were posted. I was one of the first people to post after VB had published the new rules.
I remain concerned about the omission. We should have an official, stated position with regard to racism.
"I remain concerned about the omission. We should have an official, stated position with regard to racism."-JPaul
I strongly agree!
Peace brotherdoobie
i do agree as well. there needs to be somethign about it cause racism is not cool by any means and should not be tolerated and if it is in the rules then people can not say its not in the rules so its ok or you cant do anything to me.
I did post it at the beginning of this topic, but for the benefit of those who couldn't be bothered hitting the back button on thier browser:Quote:
Originally posted by JPaul@19 October 2003 - 22:42
I didn't see the particular thread you are speaking about.
http://www.klboard.ath.cx/index.php?...pic=74891&st=0
race is prolly one of the most complicated topics anyone has to deal with socially... it's hard to distinguish what people say, from what they mean. do they really mean to be racist, or not? imho, some of the funniest humor/comedy deals with race & racism, people of all ethnicities find it amusing, and it's not meant to be genuinely racist. society can't take everything seriously, all the time, lest we all become bitter, angry people who think the world is incurably corrupt & unfair.
but then, how are people with authority (in position to censor offensive comments) supposed to deal with it? if they don't make a choice between complete tolerance of racial comments or complete intolerance, they set themselves up to be accused of only selectively applying censorship.
people in many parts of the world have direct experience with aboriginal issues (like in america, australia, new zealand, etc)... but in other regions, the aboriginals vs. settlers issue simply does not exist. so it's prolly not offensive to people who don't have a cultural knowledge of aboriginals.
imho, yes, some of those people in that thread (the one regarding movies that feature aboriginals) used racist slang and it wasn't sensitive, but they explained that it wasn't meant to be hateful and i don't think they're lying.
it's up to the admins/moderators to announce an explicit rule regarding racial discussion though, since we are all obliged to follow their rules when visiting their forum.
Intentional or not, some of the input on that topic was clearly counterproductive and intended to disrupt. One person's apparent eagerness for the topic to be closed proves that. His wholesale dismissal of indigenous Australian's film making abilities was also made very clear, in spite of being completely wrong and inappropriate.Quote:
Originally posted by 3RA1N1AC@20 October 2003 - 19:09
imho, yes, some of those people in that thread (the one regarding movies that feature aboriginals) used racist slang and it wasn't sensitive, but they explained that it wasn't meant to be hateful and i don't think they're lying.
Absolutely. This forum is a place where I come for enjoyment... I most certainly didn't want to have to play "PC policeman" in that topic. The sooner a racial clause is re-entered into the rules, the better it will be for all concerned.Quote:
it's up to the admins/moderators to announce an explicit rule regarding racial discussion though, since we are all obliged to follow their rules when visiting their forum.
OMG i read that thread posted above and i thought..... ok im expecting a huge flame war with racial slurs of many colours and flavours...
BUT no.... all i saw was one mistyped word and someone saying that "abo" aborigenal(sp) movies suck. Is that not in his opinion to hate that type of film,
I personally cant stand Indian movies, the whiny voices drive me insane (if i wasnt already) doesnt mean im racist.
People are trying to be to polictically correct. im not saying racism is right in fact i think everyone is equal, but if u ask me the only ones spouting racism around are the ones complaining about it who just take things to heart too oftern.
chinks - chinese
japs - japanese
abos - aborigenals
limeys - english
tossers - americans (joke)
wog ( derived from golly-wog the black man with white makeup on to show his paler features )
Paki - pakistani
And to take it further - Gay - Homosexual
All these words where just shorthand for the true name for the race or group, hell gay used to mean happy and bright and carefree, its only those in the gay comunity that seem to have corrupted it, you know what i mean.
now when i say gay i mean something is not working, its being stupid, like gah this pc is being gay. i dont mean it in a derogotary sense to gays, im just paraphrasing. It seems to me to be a social construct on how words have to be politcally correct to suite the minor races at the expense of tredding on a few toes.
Grow up all of you and stop thinking, just glaze over it, if something truely gets ur goat then something will be done. it may have been a petty comment... nm i give up you get the picture
Xanex
i think every body black, whilte, yellow, orance,green needs to calm down and have a bit of sense of humer about this stuff, if its not meant to be offensive you shouldn't take it that way, i myself being a sandnigger and a terrorist should know :lol: :lol:
@muscleman
Roger That Good buddy
http://smilies.sofrayt.com/%5E/w/thumbs.gifQuote:
Originally posted by Xanex@20 October 2003 - 07:00
@muscleman
Roger That Good buddy
I'm so very sorry you were disappointed by the lack of flaming, Xanex.
It may not have been as spectacular as you'd hoped, but it's the thin end of the wedge, all the same.
I have to deal with racism on a daily basis owing to my location, so I find it nearly impossible to take lightly. I don't find it at all humorous MM, so excuse me if I dont find it funny. I also would rather not have to deal with it online. Like I said before, I come here for enjoyment - not to hear the same crap I hear out on the street everyday.
I know I'm starting sound like a crank, but once this kind of thing gets started, it's near impossible to stop... so I'm simply asking for the line to be drawn here and now.
That's all I'm going to say on the subject.
so what i have to deal with it on daily basis also, you think its easy being a middle
eastern here in the usa right now or specially after 911, i lost 2 of my good friends
there and every body looks at me like i did it, but its ignorance and i won't play any
part in it, as i said before if its not meant to be ofensive then its your problem for
being soft , get yourself together and lighten up every thing has its place, if its
ofensive i would be the first to break somebody's jaw but if its not then i have fun
with it, i find it very funny how so many people can all sit back and laugh at
jokes/comments about other races but when it comes to thier own all of a sudden
its not acceptable.
racisim should not have a place any where but as long as it is racisim and not light
humor there is a difference between being offensive and joking boss, good luck and
i hope where ever you are at people will lighten up also http://smilies.sofrayt.com/%5E/b/smiley2k.gif
Xanex you seem to not really understand what it is about racism that can be cruel and still be painful to some people, just try to have some empathy. There are reasons why comments which technically are very similary likeQuote:
Originally posted by Xanex@20 October 2003 - 11:57
People are trying to be to polictically correct. im not saying racism is right in fact i think everyone is equal, but if u ask me the only ones spouting racism around are the ones complaining about it who just take things to heart too oftern.
chinks - chinese
japs - japanese
abos - aborigenals
limeys - english
tossers - americans (joke)
wog ( derived from golly-wog the black man with white makeup on to show his paler features )
Paki - pakistani
And to take it further - Gay - Homosexual
All these words where just shorthand for the true name for the race or group, hell gay used to mean happy and bright and carefree, its only those in the gay comunity that seem to have corrupted it, you know what i mean.
english = limeys
blacks = wogs
are completely different in terms of the emotional reactions of people (either on the receiving end or not). I'm sure you instinctively know this is true even if you've never bothered to work out why, just like you can usually instinctively tell when you cross the line in making a comment.
Imo having hard rules isn't necessarily the answer as that might get a bit ridiculous, personally I'm happy having a vague rule about racism and trusting the instincts of the members and mods.
Actually i was under the impression that the rules prohibited any racism outside the funny stuff section.
I know none of my friends would appreciate being called "gook" or "nigger" and so forth. I don't think strangers would appreciate it either.
:ninja:
yep also being an aussie aboriginals would not like to be called "coons"Quote:
I know none of my friends would appreciate being called "gook" or "nigger" and so forth. I don't think strangers would appreciate it either.
and btw I am a albino so I know what its like being called shit names for skin coulor it it does hurt
Ad it just occured to me that you must go through a ton of suncream each year, perhaps Australia isn't the wisest possible place to live ;) you should try England or Scotland, I heard a rumour that Faslane (famous Scottish military base) has cloud cover for a bit under 300 days a year
yeah I try to avoid going out in the summer anyway where I live is the coldest place in Australia near the mountains so it doen't really get hot here that much which is good.Quote:
Ad it just occured to me that you must go through a ton of suncream each year, perhaps Australia isn't the wisest possible place to live you should try England or Scotland, I heard a rumour that Faslane (famous Scottish military base) has cloud cover for a bit under 300 days a year
Its the eyesight thing that pises me off the most
Ill never be able to get a licence :(
People have seemed to have missed my point entirely all bar MM,
Its not the lack of flamming its the over reaction to such a silly thing, its just a shame people cant be light hearted on these small topics. From what i read on that thread and by the way uNz[i] was posting it seemed like an all out war was going on, only to upon reading that thread the comments where petty and the reactions where over rated.
Names are names as far as I see it, some American calling me a limey is no different to me callin a Nigerian a nigger.
Sticks and stones as people say. but some people are just too easily bruised.
uNz[i]
Your absolutly right, and im sorry you have to deal with this all the time with these uneducated people, but being white isnt easy either when you have every minority group treading on your toes trying to see over the top and be recognised.Quote:
Racism should never be taken lightly.
Ilw
It all depends on the person, I might just take the same reaction as the next person, but because of the person I am I just let it slide and know to myself they either are jesting or they ar4e lower than myself and I will not dignify the response.Quote:
english = limeys
blacks = wogs
are completely different in terms of the emotional reactions of people (either on the receiving end or not). I'm sure you instinctively know this is true even if you've never bothered to work out why, just like you can usually instinctively tell when you cross the line in making a comment.
If people only moved up a level to that of the racist then things would be fine, for you know in yourself that they arent worth the effort. With some exceptions but there are laws for that.
In forums like this it is so hard to modorate everything on the subject of racism, for one person may see the funny and innocent side while the other will plot the death of the said.
MM
roger that again good buddy =)Quote:
if its not meant to be ofensive then its your problem for
being soft , get yourself together and lighten up every thing has its place, if its
offensive i would be the first to break somebody's jaw but if its not then i have fun
with it
Xanex
Bad example, this one.Quote:
Names are names as far as I see it, some American calling me a limey is no different to me callin a Nigerian a nigger.
Although "Nigger" may be short for Negro, which is a Race name, its association with Slavery in particular makes it very sensitive.
Limey/Pommy etc may be funny to us, however "Nigger" is not funny to coloured people quite understandably. This is racism, pure and simple in this context.
I have used the word before, many times....to friends at the same time as they have called me Honky etc... As friends, we were kidding around wth each other and joking.
There are very few people on this board that are close enough emotionally to get away with such joking. If they are joking with each other, it will offend others....
In other words, this word is one of a few that there is no excuse for ever typing on this board.
I trust that this is the last time I see it here.
Names are names full stop, if people take offense then so be it, but as long as i know im not being abusive in the context of my writing/talking and ive made it clear to others then i dont see the problem. Although they may not see it that way, then f*ck em if they are that petty and cant use their intelligence to work it out, i consider myself quite intelligent to avoid using such descriptions in non abusive context but there are times like the above where Its in example not in racial abusivness.
Its a shame how harmless nicknames so degrade to the levels of abuse.
an insult is an insult no matter how u look at it. and above i was not directing at anyone, are we in a world where we are censored to everything we say? i hope not
limey was the fact that our navy issued us with limes in order to prevent scurvey, frankly i dont like being compared to a fruit anymore than a Negro/Nigro would like being called the said.
If i where so inclined I would take offence at this, since it refers to my race of people ( define "Race" ) , it may be funny to me but to another would be crying racism all over the place. People are so fickle at times...Quote:
Limey/Pommy etc may be funny to us, however "Nigger" is not funny to coloured people quite understandably. This is racism, pure and simple in this context
Though your right I also hope this is the last time I see it here, BUT NOT in this context, ur the mod its ur rulz. But i hope you can tell where people are being abusive and NOT informative and moderate to such.
I thought we where all friends here too???Quote:
I have used the word before, many times....to friends at the same time as they have called me Honky etc... As friends, we were kidding around wth each other and joking.
Xanex
Quote:
There are very few people on this board that are close enough emotionally to get away with such joking. If they are joking with each other, it will offend others....
We are.
However there are friends and there are friends.
I also have friends that would take great offense at the same type of joking around :( .
Other words are offensive to a majority when they get used are those such as "Paki"....short for Pakistani, yes. And most Pakistani's i know call each other this...however, it is also used to describe Indians....as most UK residents cant be bothered to know the difference.
All Indians I know are offended by this term....the same Pakistani's that call each other the word, get offended when used by "whites". It is therefor a racist term.
I do not know anyone that gets offended by the term "Limey", maybe mildly annoyed in the same way that some Americans dislike being called "Yanks" (especially the ones from Southern States ;) ). Neither term is racist, as it refers to a nationality, not a race.... It doesnt matter if your Black, White or Pink with Blue polkadots... it describes what country your from, nothing more.
You can generally tell from the context of a post if something is meant as a "Racist" comment, i agree. However some terms/words are offensive whether or not they are meant to be.
In this context.....there are words that just are not used.
With many 000s of members, you will offend people using words like this...you know this, you are not stupid.
very well said :)
I wonder why anyone with a brain would feel it neccesary to label others.
Whether it be race, creed, sexuality, hair colour, weight, looks, background, etc, etc.... , no-one likes to be singled out. Intolerance has no place in modern society.
Whats wrong wit that topic? Even you posted in it.Quote:
[i]Originally posted by uNz@18 October 2003 - 14:54
http://www.klboard.ath.cx/index.php?...pic=74891&st=0
A few people seem to be under the impression that I'm not white. That is wrong. I am white, of English and Irish extraction, raised from birth in Australia. But that isn't really relevant.
In my area, I see a lot of indigenous Australians copping a raw deal every day. I am constantly hearing small-minded bigots grumbling and cracking awful racist jokes about them behind thier backs, which I find incredibly cowardly and offensive.
My point in my comment on that topic where I dared that guy to repeat what he'd said about Indigenous filmakers talents in the Tenant Creek Bus Station is this; You wouldn't say it there, so what makes you think it's okay to say it here?
I've had the opportunity to travel to the outback and see the Indigenous Australians in the bush, away from the cities. What I saw and learned there was some of the most amazing stuff you could imagine. They are being maligned for no good reason other than that some people are incredibly ignorant and/or scared.
Ive already said I'm done talking about this issue. Since then, I've been called soft, and accused of having no sense of humour. I'm not here to play PC policeman, as I've also already said. If any of this had taken place in the Funny Stuff section, I would've stayed out of it. But it was in Movieworld, and none of it was even close to being in the form of a joke. It was completely inappropriate to the topic in hand.
All I intended to achieve with this topic is to have one word added to the forum rules.
Thats all.. it's quite simple.Quote:
Rule 2
Posts containing subject matter deemed racist, grotesque, disturbing, obscene, malicious, or of a sexual nature may be edited or deleted. Images containing complete nudity are not allowed, and nude images in which the subject(s) are topless may only be posted in the Lounge area.
Now I really am finished here.. question all you like, it'll be a waste of time. I'm leaving this topic for good and won't be back.
I leave this in the capable hands of the mods and admin.
and stuff in the movie world is not funny???
i concur with uNz[i] rat-faced jpaul nikkid and others that the racism clause needs to be expressed rather than implied in the forum rules.
adster/adthomp and wrongturn have in my opinion demonstrated much of what is wrong with australia.
i also find their ignorant textural vomit to be offensive.
@adster re. albinism & being 'the other' :: being part of a minority doesn't give you any lee-way to dis other disenfranchised groups, the fact that you should know how it feels makes you seem even smaller for making such pathetic comments
to the americans who 'can't see a problem' and who 'don't think that the thread was bad enough',
as rat faced said different people take offence at different things, the people calling the names rarely understand the offence, if you are not offended when someone else is then you probably don't understand why it could be offencive.
so just because you don't find it offencive doesn't mean that it isn't offencive