Legal experts: LimeWire likely doomed

Legal experts: LimeWire likely doomed

" A federal court judge has likely dealt a death blow to LimeWire, one of the most popular and oldest file-sharing systems, according to legal experts.

Mark Gorton, LimeWire's founder, could see a federal court decision force his company to shut down operations possibly very soon.

"It is obviously a fairly fatal decision for them," said Michael Page, the San Francisco lawyer who represented file sharing service Grokster in the landmark case, MGM Studios, vs. Grokster and also represented Lime Wire's former CTO in the company's most recent copyright case. "If they don't shut down, the other side will likely make a request for an injunction and there's nothing left but to go on to calculating damages."

With an injunction, the RIAA can force LimeWire to cease file-sharing operations. Music industry sources who spoke to CNET on condition of anonymity said the RIAA, the trade group representing the four largest music labels, is considering whether to seek an injunction prior to a status conference Wood scheduled for June 1. If that happens, LimeWire may have little room to maneuver and the company could be forced to shutter operations within weeks. Representatives for the Lime Group did not respond to interview requests. An RIAA spokesman declined to comment.

While Wood's decision won't come close to killing online piracy--there's still BitTorrent and plenty of other ways to share files--she likely has scuttled a peer-to-peer service used by nearly 60 percent of the people who download songs. She also may have ushered out the era of large, well-funded file-sharing services, at least the kind that help distribute mostly copyright-infringing content. By making Gorton personally liable for damages, Wood served notice that operating these kinds of businesses is now a very risky financial endeavor. If the RIAA gets its way, Gorton, Lime Wire, and Lime Group will collectively be responsible for paying damages of $450 million.

One way out of the mess is for Lime Wire to cut a deal with the record companies. One scenario would be for is for Lime Wire to turn itself into a legal music retail store, said Chris Castle, an entertainment lawyer who represents artists and indie labels with a long history in technology. But based on Gorton's record, Castle doubted the Gorton has any interest in creating a legitimate business. For that reason, Castle applauded Wood's decision and said he hopes the RIAA goes for an injunction as soon as possible.
____________________


Yey!, I'm very happy with this news! Limewire was an abomination of the p2p. "

| CNET

The program "LimeWire" is one thing, and the Gnutella network (the one it operates on) is another one. The latter will still work even if Limewire's development stops, but is doomed already - just look at the amount of fakes and viruses.

can't remember the last time I used limewire

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by anon-sbi

The program "LimeWire" is one thing, and the Gnutella network (the one it operates on) is another one. The latter will still work even if Limewire's development stops, but is doomed already - just look at the amount of fakes and viruses.

---

if they were just fakes...

my friend recently got kiddie porn from limewire, he was trying to download "Nirvana - Smells Like Teen Spirit". What happened to good old viruses and trojans...

Quote:

---

my friend recently got kiddie porn from limewire, he was trying to download "Nirvana - Smells Like Teen Spirit". What happened to good old viruses and trojans...

---

Sadly, and this is no joke, but I doubt that argument would stand up in court

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Expeto

my friend recently got kiddie porn from limewire, he was trying to download "Nirvana - Smells Like Teen Spirit". What happened to good old viruses and trojans...

---

Gives you an idea of how full of trash the network is.

Don't even think about downloading any tracks by the band Cream.

people still use that? i thought it was just for downloading viruses.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by anon-sbi

The program "LimeWire" is one thing, and the Gnutella network (the one it operates on) is another one.

---

yea but it will take the RIAA and the courts another 5 or 10 years to figure that one out.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Expeto

Legal experts: LimeWire likely doomed

---

It takes neither a Law degree or any form of expertise to predict that.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by bobbintb

yea but it will take the RIAA and the courts another 5 or 10 years to figure that one out.

---

The anti-P2P companies in charge of putting fake files up and slowing speeds down have already realized it.

Limewire has always had viruses in it. There's still other ways to share files.

I hope this doesn't set a precedent to make taking down other p2p methods easier. People who still use limewire for music should move on to soulseek or torrents though, they are a much better alternative

Quote:

---

Castle doubted the Gorton has any interest in creating a legitimate business.

---

:D Gotta kinda give the guy props for not going Napster...

Quote:

---

served notice that operating these kinds of businesses is now a very risky financial endeavor

---

I don't believe I have ever done this, but I have to agree with the lawyer AGAINST LimeWire on this point. The Industries are businesses; file sharing is the antithesis of business. The two should NEVER intersect.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TrueSounds

I hope this doesn't set a precedent to make taking down other p2p methods easier. People who still use limewire for music should move on to soulseek or torrents though, they are a much better alternative

---

Yeah I agree, the day I went from limewire to torrents I was looking at life in a whole differant pair fo sunglasses. Almost like the apple with Eve. :P