Rock Or Rap

[marine_aart]

I love them both, but rock on first place, tomorow I am going to within temptation

[soopaman]

Originally posted by adthomp@4 May 2003 - 15:21
Ill tell ya why its not music

wheres the melody???
how can we write a score for it????
what notes does the vocals use???
what key do they sing in????
what dynamics has the vocalist and instrument have????
wheres the solos???
wheres the harmonies????
wheres the chorus?????
Where are the guitars ???
where are the drums????
where is any stringed arrangment????

all of this is what music is and rap has nothing of the kind

This level of deliberate baiting is getting to be a habit from you Adthomp. Did you not get enough attention as a child?? Listing all the musical terms you know is not going to deflect the fact that you're pretty ignorant about the subject!!
Personally I like both forms of music although Hip-Hop definately edges it for me.

"Melody, Harmonies, Chorus, Drums"??? Adthomp you crack me up saying by "talking we are in fact singing". I think you are singing out of your arse!!

[Benno]

Originally posted by summerlinda+4 May 2003 - 16:50--></span><table border='0' align='center' width='95%' cellpadding='3' cellspacing='1'><tr><td>QUOTE (summerlinda @ 4 May 2003 - 16:50)</td></tr><tr><td id='QUOTE'><!--QuoteBegin--djhothands@4 May 2003 - 15:16
umm well i can apreciate rock as a music that atrracts a lot of people, even though i doont ersonally like it, but unlike you guys e.g. summerlinda your simply ignorant, saying that rap isnt music? ok then tell me exactly why it isnt music??? you guys dont understand the first thing about musc , ive bee a producer for abour 6 years now , and i mainly produce rap, but i have also produced ambient music and some rock....yes rock&#33; versatilty is also a key to life, and since you guys like to live the ignorant way, theres not much point in me saying anything

Shut up.... you dont even know me, otherwise you would have known i&#39;m just joking. I dont like rap at all, but if other people do, its fine with me, i respect everybody&#39;s choice of music.

Im NOT ignorant and i DO understand music Mister Producer&#33;

Lightn up Ubermensch[/b][/quote]
Summerlinda getting angry.

btw Rock

[Curley]

Guys... is there any need to throw personal insults around?? Its only music for gods sake. Everyone has differant tastes.

[WeeMouse]

damn straight Curley&#33;

:flame:

me don&#39;t like rap (in fact I can barely stand the likes of eminem etc) but i believe that as long as these songs are not played in my presence, then I have no right to complain about them&#33;

[porkshit]

Originally posted by Curley@4 May 2003 - 16:04
Guys... is there any need to throw personal insults around?? Its only music for gods sake. Everyone has differant tastes.

EXACTLY. i think all these stupid topics about what genre of music is better, or who raps better than who should all stop. everybody has a different opinion.

[Jayhawk]

i say that rock is better

[Hellhammer]

Niether,Punk and Metal all the way

[amphoteric88]

in rap/hip hop, instruments are used
Tupac - Dear Mama is a good example
full band on stage

[Ad]

Why why does everyone have to insult and buse each other???? inever abused anyone I only abused Rap itself i didnt call anyone a dumbfuck or ignorant i mearly just said i hate rap i tell me SKILLion when i said Mozart is not music?????? its what started it all i was comparing what rock has and rap doesnt so think before u post BS about me&#33;&#33;&#33; rap people can nock rock all they like even though i love it but u dont see me calling them ignorent thats there opinion and whats mine is mine I answed the question that was asked on the thread so why dont we all just give our own opionion without abuseing each other&#33;&#33;