Do you think FST should get rid of the Trading section?

**ban** · 02-26-2009, 11:33 AM

no , i think is nothing wrong if ppl want to trade trackers ,the real problem and the reason i don`t like to trade is that a lots (not all) of trader are collectors ,make more acc/trackers and make fake to buffer those accounts so they can trade , i think these are people who need to get rid not the trade section or every trade
and anyway if you remove the trade section they will become "anti-trader"

**spark** · 02-26-2009, 12:56 PM

Yes please get rid of THEM.

**Patriot foreve** · 02-26-2009, 03:48 PM

There are really some funny comments in here as (Trading is illegal),That's sentence made me laugh alot today because Piracy is illegal are we are doing it ,torrent sites are illegal and they exist so can you say that trading is illegal while you do everything illegal?

what will happen when the section is closed that we will get an influx of ass kissers/lickers and beggars in the giveaway section besides that most torrent trackers don't allow their invites to be givenaway in public forums such as fst and others so how will u solve that issues?

Removing Trading section or banning traders or such things which will arise in the future is same like dictator's decisions to ban other political parties in the country ,Traders are a large group and should be represented ,may be their ideas don't like some and no one is forced to follow that path or ideas if it don't suit them

By Removing the trading section there will be no balance in here and there will be only the ass kissing section so i vote no

**Albo Da Kid** · 02-26-2009, 04:00 PM

Originally Posted by Patriot foreve

By Removing the trading section there will be no balance in here and there will be only the ass kissing section so i vote no

Then why don't we do a test on it. Lock the trading section for 2 months or so and lets see how the situation changes. That's the only way to find out.

You can predict all you want but we'll only be sure when we see it with our own eyes.

What do you say mods? At least lock it for a few weeks

**Shalafi** · 02-26-2009, 04:09 PM

Originally Posted by Albo Da Kid

Originally Posted by Patriot foreve

By Removing the trading section there will be no balance in here and there will be only the ass kissing section so i vote no

Then why don't we do a test on it. Lock the trading section for 2 months or so and lets see how the situation changes. That's the only way to find out.

You can predict all you want but we'll only be sure when we see it with our own eyes.

What do you say mods? At least lock it for a few weeks

I advice you to listen this band.Oldies are so popular nowadays.

**(I)** · 02-26-2009, 04:10 PM

OK, I know I may start flaming, but will try to keep it good

Well, I am not trader, never traded, and like to respect my nick name and my accounts

But I voted No, yes I don't mind FST keep the trade forum
FST is to helpful because it collect all other sites staff in one place, you meet any problem you come here, to rest your password, or to know the irc channel

It's huge torrent database we all need

This db needs trading forum, because lots of users visit the site = ads = money = fst keep going
FST must be neutral, no need to obey others rules, it would be bad id fst for example stand against p2l, selling invites, that means for example TL &/or sct staff won't be here (if we supposed that tl is p2l, sct sell invites)

If TL & sct staff weren't here then, fst is just another forum, no thing special

I am pretty sure that Detale will never close the section because he knows that it's fst end if he did

As antitrader, I just remember what stoi said

They have the right to trade, and we have the right to ban them if caughted

Fair

Edit:
P.S. I even against giving away invites for free, for people you never seen, just to collect reps, but that doesn't mean we should close ga section which means close fst too
I

**stoi** · 02-26-2009, 04:27 PM

They have the right to trade, and we have the right to ban them if caughted

i must have been drunk lol

IMO, i would rather you got rid of the WTAW and kept the trading section, than get rid of the trading section, and keep the WTAW.

It puts small trackers on a pedestal, that in turn compromise their security.

What i would suggest is.

Only allow invite trading, stop account trading altogether, invite trading i am not that bothered about, OK i am but not as much as account trades, i believe that if you get into a tracker, you should work from the bottom up and proove yourself, not get an account that someone else has worked at, and be top of the tree so to speak.

and i dont see the point of the WTAW like i said in a previous post.

I know trading is wrong, but why stop them trading an invite for a lvl 9 with a lvl 4 if both parties want into those trackers, but that thread says you cant do that and if you try, you will be a laughing stock, its pointless, surely its up to them what they want to trade, or what they want to try to trade.

**cinephilia** · 02-26-2009, 04:38 PM

Originally Posted by (I)

I voted No, yes I don't mind FST keep the trade forum

Originally Posted by (I)

As antitrader, I just remember what stoi said

there's a difference between 'non trader' and 'anti trader'... claiming to be an 'anti trader' imply that you do mind if FST keep the trade section running...