What Trackers Are Worth [With Reviews and Ratings] Part 1

[taba]

Haha i got teh 1000 post wut do I git?

hahahahahaha
i didnt realize that

that was me man
ur post is 1001

RP is enough 4 both of us here
but i still welcoming with any other giveaway

[ten elite brains]

They're two separate ratings, ten elite brains. They have no correlation.

Sorry Shadowfire, that post wasn't amied at you. Your post wasn't even there when I hit reply.

I am well aware of the two rating systems, I even quoted them to make my point...

[mbucari1]

Hey, what happened to the RP rating? It's completely off the list just because it opened once in a blue moon?

[Patriot foreve]

Hey, what happened to the RP rating? It's completely off the list just because it opened once in a blue moon?

it has gone to lvl 2 now because of the open signups

[Patriot foreve]

Haha i got teh 1000 post wut do I git?

u should give not get

[mbucari1]

Hey, what happened to the RP rating? It's completely off the list just because it opened once in a blue moon?

it has gone to lvl 2 now because of the open signups

So with that reasoning, if any tracker >3 opened just once (even ScT), you would drop it to 2? This seems a little unballanced sinse demonoid is open every friday and also a level 2/

[asafisraeli123]

RP is level 2 ?!?! even WB that had open signup and the staff came here and got 50 more accounts for free and it was level 4 got down to level 3.5 only!! RP should be 4 !

[mbucari1]

Totally agree asafisraeli123, their standards are completely out of wack. Come on, Demonoid is at the same level. Iplay opened a few times in the lase few weeks and I think it only got knocked 1.

[RealitY]

Think while a site is open it shouldnt be above a level two if open more than a short time. Its in the same level as sites that are open frequently which makes sence. Having a ranking above that wouldnt make sence since while open any member can register so it has no trade value really. When it closes again in time it will be adjusted depending on how many got in and how many invites are available.

Fact is while a site is open it has no trade value and less if open for a long time. Maybe it should be a rule that if a site is open for more than a short time it goes to level two untill its closed again for awhile to be revalued again...

[mbucari1]

Think while a site is open it shouldnt be above a level two if open more than a short time. Its in the same level as sites that are open frequently which makes sence. Having a ranking above that wouldnt make sence since while open any member can register so it has no trade value really. When it closes again in time it will be adjusted depending on how many got in and how many invites are available.

Fact is while a site is open it has no trade value and less if open for a long time. Maybe it should be a rule that if a site is open for more than a short time it goes to level two untill its closed again for awhile to be revalued again...

That seems like a very logical rule Reality. As long as it does go back up EVENTUALLY, I have no problems.