What constitues a "good" game?

[Powared]

a good game for me is a good multiplayer system

[xripper]

I think that today most of the games have good graphics but they lag in a most important thing i.e. physics. Yeah, remember all the cool moves u do, break the objects, or kill the AI, physics is wat makes it interesting. Moreover the level design & the plot should also be cool enough to make u play till the end or else u get hooked up in a level & accuse the game.
For a game in short, the most important things r-
Plot, physics, gameplay, & controls.
If a game lacks the above take the game flash it in ur toilet. Thats how u treat a bad game

[Evelyn]

if someone have attended GDC this year .. the TOP priority is gameplay, People love road-rash still with that ugly graphics & pple hate Halo 3 - good visual quality but same boring gameplay.

[PowerWheels]

good graphics, gameplay and story

[Morfeus]

1st- Gameplay
2nd - story
3rd Graphics

[RedDev1l]

1) A good story
2) Gameplay
3) Multiplayer
4) Graphics

[Reekk]

Give me a good "can't stop playing, must see what happens next" story and I will play it (almost) regardless of anything else

[7th]

Good graphic + good gameplay will make me play a lot of games. What will make me want to continue playing after the third hour is, definitely, the story. And if the story is great, I'll play it to see how it ends.

[Melchior00]

1st. Game play : you can enjoy a game with no story.. just need a minimal context -> sport games. after all, that the essence of gaming.. you input commands from your gamepad..
2st. Overall design : Shadow of colossus is a good example for that matter. deep and original environment yet, with a minimal story
3st. Story : put flesh on the bones and you may get a good game out of something technically limited. => any jap old school rpgs..

[dirizabl]

Gameplay is the most important segment of a game, for me. If game is having a good concept, I will play it and support it, no matter for graphics and sound.