What constitues a "good" game?

[LtAda]

Good multiplayer
Good controls
Good graphics
Addicting concept

[imran4]

Hi to all.
I am new here. In my opinion, for a good game. Graphic wise should be on the top.
When playing, our interest should be develop in it.

[anon]

In my opinion, for a good game. Graphic wise should be on the top.

No, it shouldn't.

This "shit" has kept me entertained for years:

[IdolEyes787]

I think I mentioned it several pages back but nudity and foul language is always a big plus.
Barring that guns and swords hopefully involving the decapitation of the living dead or the pinnacle of videogame achievement the gunsword (gunblade) like the one Squall had in FF something or other.

I don't think any amount of plot or workable controls or "graphical enhancement " is ever gong to be able to top that. Might just as well stop making new ones right now in my opinion.