Saw...or The Grude?

[iMartin]

Which one is scarrier? The Grudge, or Saw? I've only seen Saw advertised once, but it looks kinda freaky, but The Grudge just looks flat out fucking scary as hell.

[cpt_azad]

the grudge, no competition there. the saw isn't scary at all in my opinion.

[iMartin]

What's Saw about any ways...

[ApacNTS]

saw is about a maniac who finds ways for victimes to kill themselves, in a strange puzzle, he actually reveals himself, well at the end anyay, it's not who you think either. i thought it was a good movie, cant say scary, but good. as far as the grudge goes, the original is getting huge hype, so this one should be good as well. now all i gotta do is wait for ring 2

[iMartin]

Oi...The Ring is scary as all god given hell too.

[winston856]

The GRUDGE!!

It made me jump like 3 times....

The ring is NOT scary...

[cpt_azad]

the ring was alright, it wasn't scary, but it didn't help me with trying to sleep @ night after watchin it , it's the atmosphere that the ring created, a "disturbing" theme if you will, it was scary but not the crap your pants scary-type. gonna see the grudge tom. can't wait

[ofbz]

yeah... you're right... "the ring" IMO, falls into the "disturbing" type of horror... although it does make you jump in a couple of scenes...

how is the grudge anyways... one of my friend saw it, and she says is really scary.... but the pg-13 rating doesn't convince me for some reason...

by "how is it" i mean, is it disturbing, or does it make you jump for a couple of seconds and then you forget about it...

[iMartin]

yeah... you're right... "the ring" IMO, falls into the "disturbing" type of horror...

True...true.

[Jordank87]

I saw both grudge and saw. Id have to say i liked saw 10times better just of the thought that the ending kicked so much ass lol, pretty much the whole movie did. On the other hand the grudge IS a scarier movie, but i liked saw a lot better. Anyone else agree with me?