Harry Potter Book 5 Discussion

[WeeMouse]

I think It should be Ginny........

I didn't see the death coming - I have to admit I thought that Sirius couls have become much more important to the story, but at the same time I'm very glad it wasn't say, Hagrid, cos i would have cried and cried!

[dlingeverything]

Originally posted by WeeMouse@28 June 2003 - 15:56
I think It should be Ginny........

I didn't see the death coming - I have to admit I thought that Sirius couls have become much more important to the story, but at the same time I'm very glad it wasn't say, Hagrid, cos i would have cried and cried!

I dont think it would have been ginny since there had been
so much stress on her in #2

I agree that this book was lacking and hastily written. I do hope
that the "real" books will show more promise.

Sirius was the only person that harry could relate to as a real
parental figure. Maybe Rowling didnt want this for something in
the future. Maybe she threw him away since he wasn't going
to fit into the storyline of #6&#7. Maybe she just used it to lead
to the prophecy??

I found it strange that the book talked a lot more about grawp
and Cho then about Sirius's death.






--Predictions-- (look away if you need to)


-Dumbledore dies in end while fighting voldemort
-Harry rises up and defeats voldemort with his strange "power"
-Harry becomes Headmaster of Hogwarts,
-Hermione becomes a teacher,
-Ron a quidditch player.
-No Harry&Cho, rather Harry&hermione.
-In one of the books, The Trio thinks that Snape is back with the Death Eaters. They find all this evidence that he is but later find they were wrong and he is still with Order.

Grawp will have to factor in there somewhere since the book put quite a bit of text
into him.

hmm thats all i can think of

[Xelotath]

The Dias and the Viel had something important to do with Sirius' death. Luna at the end had mentioned something about it. I am thinking that some how Sirius will still be a factor in Harry's life. Rowling just "offed" him it seems, which is an unlikely thing to happen.

[judgeofallandnothing]

maybe grawp will convince SOME of the giants to join the cause

[olibomb]

i'm on page 300 and it's better than the other 1's already

[Dieselpower]

The fifth book is definetaly worser than third and fourth books.
Written like a movie script...

[Xelotath]

Interesting that it is written like a script when i hear they are going to stop making the moies after #3

[tuvas]

Do you honestly think they'd stop entirely making movies that are selling that many tickets? They are only pausing momentarily, to resume probably sometime fairly soon.

[Xelotath]

Yeah you are prolly right. I never liked the movies much though. Hopefully the third one will be better.

[tuvas]

Well, there's only so much they can do, the books are great, but to put the whole book into the movie would take far too much time. But as HP1 was second in the total box office ever after Titanic, also the second movie to ever break the billion dollar sum, they'll keep making movies I'm certain of it.