Printable View
well like i said try 7 any way if it is a fake its a realy good one writen in the same style as rowling i would not doubt at all that 7 is a fake as its not the whole year at hogworts like the rest but ti is a good read
and 1 more time i got 5 a month ago before it was released and it is defenatly not a fake its the real deal
so thee not as secure as the auther seems to think
ya, the 7 is definately a fake since she hasn't even started writing it yet. but I'm gonna give 5 a try
QuietSilence! - Your book 5 is a fake. It is fan fiction. there is another version of that same copy that has the author (not Rowling) discussing why, how, and when he wrote the book. (he is a high-schooler).
If you don't take my word for it, the publisher has released this statement:
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, by J.K. Rowling, the fifth in the bestselling series has been scheduled for release on Saturday, June 21, 2003.
"We are thrilled to announce the publication date. Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix is absolutely superb and will delight all J.K. Rowling's fans. She has written a brilliant and utterly compelling new adventure, which begins with the words:
"The hottest day of the summer so far was drawing to a close and a drowsy silence lay over the large, square houses of Privet Drive.... The only person left outside was a teenage boy who was lying flat on his back in a flowerbed outside number four.
"Later in the novel, J.K. Rowling writes:
"Dumbledore lowered his hands and surveyed Harry through his half-moon glasses. 'It is time,' he said 'for me to tell you what I should have told you five years ago, Harry. Please sit down. I am going to tell you everything.'
-Barbara Marcus, President of Scholastic Children's Books in the United States, and Nigel Newton, Chief Executive of Bloomsbury Publishing in Britain
Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix is over 255,000 words compared with over 191,000 words in Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire. The new book is 38 chapters long, one more than Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
In your version of book 5, it does not begin with those words.
this fanfic has the begining as him sleeping in in the summer, or something along those lines. (not him in the flowerbed, as is in the real book.)
And it also does not have the "dumbledore lowered is hands" part anywhere in it either. (I used the find feature).
Chances are a fake is not going to be released anytime soon.
Perhaps you should do a bit more research before saying for certain that is is indeed book 5.
Note: you can find the authors remarks at a plethora or harry potter fan sites, amazon, and other book sellers.
ur right its a fake both are but if u read it u wont be able to tell it its vary good and just as good as anything that rowling wrote 7 was a little difrent but still a good read
also i say again it dose not matter when the releace is for a book i have got many many books before they where released
not only books but movies and software so that arugment is not worth wile and when i got that book 5 the publisher had not released any info on it all i could go by was that it was in the exact same style as rowling if any thing it was better then the first 4
btw i have renaned thes books to
Rowling, J. K - Harry Potter FanFiction - Harry Potter and the Psychic Serpent.pdf
Rowling, J. K - Harry Potter FanFiction - Harry Potter and the Triangle Prophecy.rtf
note: left rowlings name in so they sort together. i dont realy care who the real auther is anyway also im adding 2 more fan fictions to the set the ones on the sight **no direct downloads!** havent read these yet so i dont know how good they are
but the names are
Rowling, J. K - Harry Potter FanFiction - no name1.doc
Rowling, J. K - Harry Potter FanFiction - no name2.doc
the guy used the same name as rowlings 5 and 6 so i made them no name 1 and 2
Im glad to see that.
about the release date thing - i understand where you come from, as many things do come out on the internet before the actual release date.
but - many people ask for books months before the release date, and as many authors only finish their books about a ~month(s) before they are published, and even then they go through edititing and such.
The time it takes to actually print out the books in relatively short.
as such, even though you now know that the book 7 is a fake also, that at one time you believed the possiblity that it could be real is unimaginable. the publishers rush rowlings books out the door as soon as she finsihes them.
I really doubt that she is very far into 6, let alone 7.
also, the security for books as popular for this would make it extremely hard to leak a copy(or steal one).
be no means are every, or even alot (of), book(s) released on the internet early.
everyones best bet is to go be the release dates.
note: as I re-read this, I sound harsh to my own ears. Dont mean to be. Your awesome. Used your list many and much. many thanks for it.
also. I read the book over the weekend, and I think rowling is much better.(though by no means is she one of my favorite authors.)
personally i hate harry potter
to much for kids :P
acualy she prob has writen all the books but the publishers are only releaceing them 1 a year or so this is a vary commin pratice as it makes peps want the books more and they go out right a way and get them
basily they make more money that way. they release the hard back 6 months later the paper back and 6 month later the newest hard back uasly a minimum of 3 months between releases in a series
also didnt the news releace say that 2 of her new books where stolen from the publisher? may be not i didnt read it just heard about it here
no u wernt harsh i made the mistake of saying 5 was defenatly the real thing cuse i could not see a diffrense in the wrighting style and had no info other wise the other book 7 i kida suspeted it may be fake and the other 2 from fan fiction sight i knew where fake. but 5 was a realy good fake so i figured it was real
oh well live and learn :)
ok like so much to say and so little time
1 hpfanfic is a site devoted to hp
2 fanfic cant you under stand its just a shortened word fan fiction get it well basically fans write storys called fanfics that use the same charcters settings etc but they make up the story if you dumbareses did your reasearch the boy who made it or "harrywriter" his forum name in his forum (hint hint )\(wait ill spell it out for you h a r r y w r i t e r get it now)
3 no seven cant possibly be out yet
4 yes good suggestion quiet silence but i dont think she would do that
5 it is poss that 5 is on the net i am searching kazaa 4 it now
6 you can also talk about hp on my hp forum if you like it please no "people who dont like hp"
hp forum
Ok, did you read her 'stupid/hate mail' section? It says all through there "READ THE FAQ..... THESE ARE NOT THE REAL BOOKS. I WROTE THEM MYSELF."
Read the title of the site. "Harry Potter FAN FICTION". Is it clear now or do I have to spell it out for you?
T-H-E-S-E-B-O-O-K-S-A-R-E-F-A-K-E-!
:P YEA!!!! I got stars!!!!! Happy day! (And on a flame post too! Dubble points! :P )
her?Quote:
Originally posted by tzone+28 May 2003 - 07:09--></span><table border='0' align='center' width='95%' cellpadding='3' cellspacing='1'><tr><td>QUOTE (tzone @ 28 May 2003 - 07:09)</td></tr><tr><td id='QUOTE'> <!--QuoteBegin--Got_memory?@21 May 2003 - 23:23
Ok, did you read her 'stupid/hate mail' section? It says all through there "READ THE FAQ..... THESE ARE NOT THE REAL BOOKS. I WROTE THEM MYSELF."
Read the title of the site. "Harry Potter FAN FICTION". Is it clear now or do I have to spell it out for you?
T-H-E-S-E-B-O-O-K-S-A-R-E-F-A-K-E-!
:P YEA!!!! I got stars!!!!! Happy day! (And on a flame post too! Dubble points! :P )
H-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-S
H-I-S
H-I-SH-I-SH-I-S
H-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-S
H-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-S
H-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-S
H-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-SH-I-S
H-I-S
<span style='color:red'>H-I-S</span> [/b][/quote]
I reckon some fools from the publishers of harry potter have already done some scam and got paid for it! Probably the reason how the two books got found on the feild!
Its quite impossible to run into such a gaurded book printing as harry potter 5 and then run back out, and it would be even more stupid to drop it on a feild!
Maybe someone was supposed to pick it up, but instead that guy found it and (like a dumb ibiot) gave it to the papers!