http://www.npr.org/templates/story/s...ryId=134807449
Teacher Letter To Ariz. Lawmaker Leads To Inquiry
by The Associated Press
text size A A A PHOENIX March 23, 2011, 10:28 pm ET A metropolitan Phoenix school district has launched an inquiry into a substitute teacher who wrote a letter that portrayed Hispanic students in a harsh light and was read aloud last week at the Arizona Legislature during a debate on an immigration bill.
The Glendale Elementary School District said it has determined that some statements by teacher Tony Hill in his letter to Senate President Russell Pearce were inaccurate.
In the letter, Hill said a majority of the eighth-graders he had recently taught at a Glendale school had refused to say the Pledge of Allegiance and declared that Americans had stolen their land. Hill also wrote that while substitute teaching in the area, he came to believe that "most of the Hispanic students do not want to be educated but rather (want to) be gang members and gangsters."
The letter quickly inflamed the immigration debate in Arizona. A Republican in the Legislature read the letter on the Senate floor during the immigration debate. Democrats expressed suspicion that it was a hoax that had no place in the public debate on immigration.
District spokesman Jim Cummings said all students questioned in the inquiry have said everyone stood for the pledge and that none said their land had been stolen. "What we are finding here — and what we believe — is that the statements that he made weren't accurate," Cummings said.
A recorded message on Hill's phone said his number had been changed or disconnected. He didn't return two e-mails seeking comment on Wednesday afternoon.
The letter was distributed to other Republican senators by Pearce and was read last Thursday by another senator as lawmakers debated one of five bills on illegal immigration. Among the bills considered was one that would require the parents of students at K-12 schools to prove the citizenship of their children.
The district believes the instance that Hill referred to in his letter came during his March 8 stint teaching reading, writing and social studies at Harold W. Smith Elementary School in Glendale.
Substitutes are required to fill out a report after their teaching stint, and Hill made no reference in the form to the Pledge of Allegiance or land claims made in the letter. He did state that students "refused to act proper" but didn't provide specifics in that category or in the section about "inappropriate behavior."
The letter was the subject of heated exchanges on the Senate floor Wednesday as Pearce refused to apologize.
"It's read on the floor as factual," said Democratic Sen. Steve Gallardo of Phoenix, the Senate's most outspoken critic of the letter.
Pearce said no one from the Senate owes an apology for reading the letter. "It was all verified," Pearce said. "I'm disappointed that we assault and attack a teacher for speaking out."
He said the letter wasn't about Hispanics, but rather was about what went on in a classroom where students were disruptive.
In an interview after the debate, Republican Sen. Lori Klein, who read the letter aloud on the Senate floor last week, said she didn't regret bringing to light a teacher's experience, but that she doesn't believe all Hispanic students want to be gang members.
As to whether she believes the school district's findings thus far, Klein said, "I don't think the district wants to be embarrassed," Klein said.
The district had said earlier this week that it had no record of a Tony Hill or Anthony Hill working as a substitute. But Cummings said Wednesday that a closer inspection of records showed that Hill worked as a substitute teacher in the district for nine days this school year as an employee for a temporary service that provides teachers when the district's regular fill-ins aren't available.
Since Hill isn't a district employee, any discipline against Hill would be left up to the temporary service, Cummings said, noting though that he doubts any of the district's principals would be comfortable having him as a substitute at their schools.
A message left for Teachers On Call, the service that sent Hill to the district, wasn't immediately returned Wednesday afternoon.
TwitterFacebookShareStumble UponRedditLinkedinDiggWhat is this?
Share Comments (3)Recommend (0)
More U.S.
Youths And Gun Violence: Chicago's Challenge
Chicago's Silent Watchmen Guard School Route
Officials in Chicago are enlisting veterans to help protect kids on their way to and from school.
Governing
Obama Agency Review Looks To Snip The Red Tape
The president wants to streamline government to improve the economy, but may run into some pitfalls.
Around the Nation
U.S. Overhauls Approach To BP Spill Probe
The Justice Department has put a veteran mob prosecutor in charge of a new special task force.
Comments
Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the NPR.org Community rules and terms of use. See also the Community FAQ.
You must be logged in to leave a comment. Login / Register
More information is required for you to participate in the NPR online community. Add this information
Post this comment to Facebook, too?
NPR reserves the right to read on the air and/or publish on its website or in any medium now known or unknown the e-mails and letters that we receive. We may edit them for clarity or brevity and identify authors by name and location. For additional information, please consult our Terms of Use.
Recent First Oldest First Most Recommended nicoline smits (Domela) wrote:
It's a bit late in the day to get worked up about, but it's true that the U.S. stole Mexican land. However, if those 8th graders have such a problem with it, maybe they should live elsewhere. Why torment yourself, right? And that would prevent them from having to receite the Pledge of Allegiance, too.
Thursday, March 24, 2011 7:00:21 AM
Recommend (0)
Report abuse
R Bee (Riccard) wrote:
Or Jason Richwine on the disparities with previous waves of immigration:
"The consequences of a large ethno-cultural group’s lagging behind the majority in education and income are significant. In strictly economic terms, perpetually poor immigrants and their descendants will be a major strain on social spending and infrastructure. Health care, public education, welfare payments, the criminal justice system, and programs for affordable housing will all require more tax dollars. When pro-immigration conservatives declare that these government programs should be scaled back or eliminated entirely, I am sympathetic. But a large public sector is a reality that cannot be wished away — we will not be abolishing Medicaid or public schools anytime soon. Immigration policy needs to take that reality into account."
http://nrd.nationalreview.com/articl...ZjMWZiZDY4YzQ=
Thursday, March 24, 2011 1:47:46 AM
Recommend (2)
Report abuse
R Bee (Riccard) wrote:
Mr Hill is a man of unusual courage. Aside from these anecdotal reasons to avoid cultural takeover, the legislators could also consider some of the reasons set out by Marty Nemko.
"
And what about the millions of people worldwide who have patiently waited so they can immigrate to the US legally? Can we expect they’ll continue to wait? Or will they just come on in, accelerating the overwhelming of America.
This is sad, not only for America, but for the world. For example, developing nations benefit from a US government and a Corporate America wealthy enough to invest in those countries. For example, when US corporations establish operations in developing nations, they pay employees much more than the country’s prevailing wages and offer far better working conditions. So, a dying America contributes to declining standard of living to people around the globe.
By having de facto suspended our immigration laws, we will soon be just another of the world’s countries struggling just to cope with its own residents’ poverty."
http://www.martynemko.com/articles/o...america_id1253
Bookmarks